News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:5G Beam-Steering Antennas: More Accurate, Less Power Hungry by jacquesm on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @10:14PM (#17405328)
That is an excellent question.

The answer is super complex and many factors play a role in the technical bits - if we ignore the commercial bits.

DSL lines are capacitively coupled to ground over their entire run length. This limits the frequency at which the line will operate reliably (a typical DSL modem will perform a whole series of tests to figure out which bands are 'safe' to use).

Other factors are dodgy connections in the line, other DSL lines in the same trunk cable causing interference, crappy termination causing impedance mis-match between the transmission lines and the driver hardware and limited usable bandwidth for a carrier wave to superimpose your data on top of. The smaller the available frequency band(s) the less data you can send.

Think of 'POTS' (the Plain Old Telephone Service) wiring as just about the worst possible means of transporting data that you could find. All things considered that DSL works at all is a small miracle and it took a good bit of engineering and some changes to the infrastructure (mostly the removal of the boost coils in the lines) to allow it to work.

LTE ('air' as you call it) has a huge advantage. It starts off as a GHz range carrier signal with modulation bands up to 200MHz wide (but more typically between 20 and 60MHz). That's an awful lot of bandwidth. The lack of connectivity is made up for by having a fairly dense network of base stations.

Of course you need to share those base stations with everybody else but as long as it is just you you can see phenomenal speeds, far in excess of what your DSL line is capable of.

If your DSL line could use carrier frequencies in the 100's of MHz without losing definition then DSL could be just as fast. Unfortunately the physical medium is crap and there isn't much to be done about that short of replacing it with coax (and that's called cable, and it's faster than DSL if you are on your own but - again - you will share that run of coax with a lot of your neighbours).

Re:5G Beam-Steering Antennas: More Accurate, Less Power Hungry by vvanders on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @11:43PM (#17405615)
> All things considered that DSL works at all is a small miracle and it took a good bit of engineering and some changes to the infrastructure (mostly the removal of the boost coils in the lines) to allow it to work.

Indeed, brings to mind DSL over wet string[1] that was posted here a while back[2].

[1] https://www.revk.uk/2017/12/its-official-adsl-works-over-wet...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15908107