News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Toward a Mature Science of Consciousness by naasking on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @02:01PM (#17402751)
If you want the nuanced argument: not requiring dualism to explain consciousness is indeed a belief, but founded on a long history of scientific success in toppling similar matters, and an analogously long history of failure to convince that consciousness will not fit into a scientific framework (for analogous reasons of vitalism's failure to do the same for life).

So on balance of evidence, there is little reason to think dualism will ever be required and considerable reason to think it will not. So much so, that I firmly stand by my original statement.

To clarify the "unconvincing philosophical speculation", I meant thought experiments, like p-zombies, that are supposed to convince one that there is something more to consciousness than can be captured by materialism, but which primarily appeal to vague intuitions and make use of semantic tricks of natural language to convince people that there's something of substance going on.

There are no comments on this comment yet.