Vimeo was around first and focused on 1080/HD content, and had actual enforcement of community guidelines that accounts should only be uploading content they made or took part in. YouTube (pre-Google) was gaining massive popularity with South Park and other TV content chopped into 12 minute segments to get past then-current restrictions for length. Vimeo was a better experience for community, but YouTube was a better experience for audience desires.
(I work for Google Cloud but opinions are sure my own)
It's like trying to compete with Amazon on price and delivery speed, you're going to run out of money before you make a dent.
Look at Twitch for example, it's keeping its head in the game by starting out so different YouTube is now trying to keep up with it
I understand that doesn't help current creators but the problem YouTube competitors have right now seems to be a cycle of trying to match features, run out of money, shut down
My theory is any site with a chance of toppling YouTube needs to avoid trying to topple YouTube directly and rather recreate its rise to the top