Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview...
by bborud on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:34PM
(#17411092)
> So for example Erdos didn't actually do anything
He most certainly did. In his field, doing the work which is then published in papers _is_ doing something. However, just having an idea for how to work out a mathematical proof, but not doing it would represent, well, not doing it.
I don't see how this would be unclear.
Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview...
by hindsightbias on Sunday June 24, 2018 @12:07PM
(#17387034)
> So the right time, right place, right idea is still the combination needed
And the right people.
It's a matter of degree right?
So for example Erdos didn't actually do anything - in the sense that we're talking - such as creating products or works of physical art. His mathematics are ideas. Which people then used, but critically referenced Erdos as their originator.
From what I can tell of Ted Nelson, the design and cybernetics ideas were obvious enough that many other people thought of them also, or were not so obscure as to be canonical. So like many ideas without fathers, it's whomever can create a product around them which get the credit.
So for example "Steve Jobs invented the iPhone." Anyone with even a shallow historical understanding of handheld computing knows that this statement isn't true in any concrete sense, but because Apple, under Jobs' management, popularized the smartphone the attribution goes as such. Many people thought of, and wrote about or made in science-fiction the smart phone - so it was an obvious enough idea (by then) that execution is what mattered.
Interestingly, if you push all the way back to writers like HG Wells, they predicted much of the technology we see today including smartphones, but they aren't credited with "inventing" them or even being important in their development really. So the right time, right place, right idea is still the combination needed to stand out.