News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Sunday June 24, 2018 @01:58AM (#17385168)
There is, without a doubt, a Bitcoin cult. Or more generally, crypto-currency cults.

The headline reads like it's only a cult, which isn't the case. Even the most critical observer must concede that these distributed networks are novel and interesting.

The farther you move from social media, the less cult-like things get. The best discussion remains on listservs, and there is a lot of interesting and substantive discussion occurring.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by simias on Sunday June 24, 2018 @05:09AM (#17385707)
>Even the most critical observer must concede that these distributed networks are novel and interesting.

Frankly that's besides the point these days. Lurk in cryptocurrency subreddits for a while and see that hardly anybody talks about the technology anymore, it's all about "memes" and very dubious projections. Things like this for instance: https://i.redditmedia.com/51566F6-xO0zIBDD7HzYRZyEGhDpMqQpAr... (fresh off the bitcoin subreddit front page).

I mean, look at TFA, part of the confusion stems from the fact that many people in the community simply didn't know how PoW functions (or even what it is in the first place). It's not about technology anymore, it reads like a Multi-Level Marketing forum. Nobody cares about what it is, they just want to get rich.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by jhobag on Sunday June 24, 2018 @02:06PM (#17387568)
you're using r/bitcoin as an example? one of the most well known cryptocurrency subs for toxicity and juvenile mods
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by simias on Monday June 25, 2018 @03:48AM (#17390641)
Doesn't really matter for the community mindset I'm talking about. See /r/btc/, /r/cryptocurrency and dozens more, it's mostly discussions about the price of cryptocurrency, dubious long term projections, memes and very little technical discussion.

Even articles about a potential application of Blockchain technology are generally met from an angle of "what coin is this going to pump?" See for instance: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/8ti8z9/thek... . Nobody talks about anything besides trading.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by woogiewonka on Monday June 25, 2018 @09:55AM (#17392411)
I suspect a large number of comments across any crypto sub are from fake accounts - marketing teams, account farms, team members themselves. The level of fraud and scam in crypto now is so high, it's hard to distinguish genuine comments from fake stuff.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by jenga22 on Sunday June 24, 2018 @02:31AM (#17385280)
A lot of things are cults and it doesn't have to do much with social media or the behaviors he is outlining.

Apple - You can argue Apple, the hardware company, is a cult. The fans are rabid in their support for the company. Often the discussions are not at all civil and in this particular case there is no financial incentive.

Let's move even farther away.

There are cults for clothing companies. Companies that make drinks. Gaming companies. Youtube streamers. Heck, there even cults in processor companies.

Take for example AMD. I have had chats with people who just get livid when Intel vs. AMD conversations come up and I am thinking to myself "We are talking about CPUs right?".

There are even cults with Operating Systems. Just ask the nix vs. Windows folks. Those discussions get heated.

So I am not sure what he is trying to argue here. There will always be folks developing who will have a civil discourse and try to make the currency better and then there will be the peanut gallery. That comes with anything that gains wider exposure.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by SlowRobotAhead on Sunday June 24, 2018 @02:50AM (#17385336)
I think maybe you are confusing or just being hyperbolic on the difference between fan club and religious devotion.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by sgt101 on Sunday June 24, 2018 @03:15AM (#17385401)
There are many differences (of course!) but one common strand is that both are elements of the adherent's identity. In the case of Crypto there is another defining commonality - which is life style and life chances. Religions provide a vehicle (the community) which provides adherents with different chances from those outside, Crypto does the same - via money... if you have invested you might be rich, or poor, but your life is changed.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by jenga22 on Sunday June 24, 2018 @03:26AM (#17385425)
Right. I agree. I am also going one step further and arguing that crypto is more of a fan club then a cult. There are cults way stronger that illicit a far greater emotion reaction that crypto.

Even now, when the price is in the toilet, a lot of really smart people are having sane discussions across sub-reddits. And those very smart people are still checkin in code and making improvements.

This has happened before. During the BBS era and ARPA Net era, a lot of people said those things were "cute" and only used by underground cult figures. They said that people who believed in the "internet" were dillusional that a global network would ever happen. They also said that it would have limited impact on society. They said it would stay largely with universities. Newspapers laughed. Television networks laughed. Music companies shrugged it off. But the one thing I learned from both those eras is if there are a lot of smart people working in it then it is not to be discounted.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 24, 2018 @04:44AM (#17385636)
> BBS era and ARPA Net era

These services were launched to solve a practical problem. Bitcoin was launched as the manifestation of an ideology.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by xorcist on Sunday June 24, 2018 @07:36AM (#17386121)
Right. Everyone disagreeing must surely be on ideological basis as there can be no rational basis for disagreements. As seen in everything from politics to musical taste.

Bitcoin solved some practical problem in someone's mind too, even if that problem was "how do we get private money into the 21st century?".

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by api on Sunday June 24, 2018 @11:10AM (#17386823)
Ideology played a huge role in BBSes and Arpanet too. The same kind of cyber libertarianism popular in bitcoin was popular in the BBS world, and Arpanet was created to help America win the cold war.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by jenga22 on Sunday June 24, 2018 @05:16AM (#17385732)
You sure about that? Arpanet was created to exchange short messages in case of a nuclear attack on the United States rendered all above ground communication and survivability useless. I hardly consider that a practical use case. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Internet_during_the_Cold_W...

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 24, 2018 @05:30AM (#17385764)
The U.S. government considered it a practical problem. That’s why they paid for it.

If it helps, replace “practical problem” with “a problem customers will pay you to solve.” ARPANET had that. Bitcoin, on the other, never had an original sale. It was mined as a curiosity and then jumped from narrative (“currency of the future!”) to narrative (“store of value!”) to narrative (“mostly goes up!”)

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by jenga22 on Sunday June 24, 2018 @06:42AM (#17385960)
What the U.S. considers a practical problem often isn't. That is a shitty statement. The U.S. also considered spending 2T on a jet that was worse than the F-22. Just because the U.S. spends on something doesn't mean it has a practical application.

Nevertheless, the internet turned out to be transforming from its original purpose. We can sit here and argue about cyrptocurreny but the game is young and we wont know what it will turn into in 30 years. Just like the people in the 70 and 80s didn't know how transforming the internet would become for our society.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 24, 2018 @06:52AM (#17385993)
> What the U.S. considers a practical problem often isn't

Sure. But it’s still a customer making a purchase. That purchase grounds the project in someone’s need. A need they’re willing to trade for. The “trades for” part is important, since it references the status quo.

Financial assets, particularly speculative assets, don’t solve a need. They promise to solve a future need. (Sometimes they don’t.) Part of the discipline of speculating investing is knowing when to pull the plug.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by canjobear on Sunday June 24, 2018 @10:36AM (#17386716)
On a scale of “practical” to “ideological” I’d say building a system to exchange messages in the event of catastrophe leans heavily toward practical. You can see this because governments of a wide variety of ideological persuasions would be interested in this.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by dnomad on Sunday June 24, 2018 @03:50AM (#17385489)
But this is true of all groups. All groups offer identity and possibility of growth. What makes cults special is the element of faith. This is the difference between an investor and a speculator, an engineer and a magician, and real currencies that can be used to pay taxes and exchange tokens like gold/bitcoin/beanie babies. Cryptocurrencies are inviting their members to take a leap of faith on a mechanism that is not subject to rational analysis and be rewarded with riches beyond their wildest dreams. The beauty here is that there's social proof -- in the form of actual crypto millionaires and lots of fancy whitepapers from smart people and open-source code that anybody can download and review. This attracts irrational players into the game (which in turns attracts more predators since irrational players are easy money). There's a vicious cycle at work and eventually the whole game is dominated by irrationality and delusion.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by codetrotter on Sunday June 24, 2018 @05:05AM (#17385697)
> Apple - You can argue Apple, the hardware company, is a cult. The fans are rabid in their support for the company. Often the discussions are not at all civil and in this particular case there is no financial incentive.

According to Wikipedia, Apple has sold 1.2 billion+ iPhones. Are you going to tell me that all of those people are going to “rabidly” support Apple?

No way.

What you are seeing is a very vocal very small minority.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by pdpi on Sunday June 24, 2018 @05:12AM (#17385715)
Not all people in the cryptocurrency space are followers of the cult either, though
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by codetrotter on Sunday June 24, 2018 @05:40AM (#17385793)
Indeed. That was also my point though I didn’t say it explicitly, but probably should have.

What I said applies not only to Apple but to a lot of different groups of people.

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by floatboth on Sunday June 24, 2018 @07:06AM (#17386032)
> these distributed networks are novel and interesting

They were interesting when the bitcoin paper was released.

Then people (outside of the cult) realized that you Do Not Need A Trustless System. Society is built on trust. Wasting ENORMOUS amounts of power just to replace a few trusted entities with 51% of the network is a horrible idea.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCHab0dNnj4

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by dnomad on Sunday June 24, 2018 @03:37AM (#17385448)
> The headline reads like it's only a cult, which isn't the case.

Bitcoin sold itself as a cult from the very beginning so it's no surprise that all manner of cults have congregated around the technology. Bitcoin is an interesting example of a paranoid technology: it purports to be "trustless" and perfectly "fair" and it requires only a "faith" in math. The reality is very different but it's no surprise such a marketing pitch would appeal to the paranoid style that dominates these groups.

Communities that don't value trust accumulate paranoiacs and then become prone to delusion. This is the self-defeating logic that dooms cults in the end: delusions can persist for a while, until they don't, and the real world wins. With Bitcoin I suspect the real world will win once the miners, having extracted 95% of the value from the trade, leave and turn their fleets towards more profitable ventures. This is the real bubble [1] at work, after all, and compared to this all the schemes and schemes and wacky delusions promoted by the holders is nothing.

[1] https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate?timespan=all

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by plankers on Sunday June 24, 2018 @03:59AM (#17385518)
After spending a few years in the bitcoin space, I avoid anything at the nexus of crypto and social media like the plague. You can almost always find interesting folks to chat with and answer your questions on IRC.
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by wozniacki on Sunday June 24, 2018 @03:13AM (#17385398)
You care to list some of those listservs / fora for those interested?
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by tekromancr on Sunday June 24, 2018 @02:11AM (#17385217)
If you don't mind me asking, what are some listservs worth reading?
Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by plankers on Sunday June 24, 2018 @04:01AM (#17385523)
The bitcoin-dev mailing list is quite technical, but can be quite amusing when egos begin to clash.

https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-d...

Re:Bitcoin is a Cult by lamontcg on Sunday June 24, 2018 @04:14PM (#17388190)
> Even the most critical observer must concede that these distributed networks are novel and interesting.

Nope.

Anything you can do with blockchain you can do simpler and easier and cheaper either with a standard database, or something like git with signed git commits and a trusted third party.

The blockchain exists to try to remove trusted third parties but leads to every increasing energy consumption or order to fuel incentive for "proof of work", and the coin concept is a flat out ponzi scheme.

All these ideas need to get relegated to the dustbin of history.