News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by DonHopkins on Saturday June 23, 2018 @07:23PM (#17384012)
I love his criticism of IBM (and the literary adjective that perfectly describes IBM that I learned today):

Q: Tell me about IBM?

A: What would you like to know? OMINOUS LAUGH

Q: Well, I'd like to know what's wrong with them, to start with, since that's what you want to talk about.

A: Ok. IBM is first and foremost a very slick sales organization, which was created in the image of Thomas J. Watson, a supreme despot, and very imaginative salesman who managed to create an organization with less fat in -- pardon me -- less local fat than any other corporation that ever happened.

And one that has over the years learned to devote teams to getting things done. That's the positive side. Get these things done with dispatch and with earnestness.

Now whether they're done the way one would like to see them done if one contemplated what the real nature of a problem, this is and entirely different manner. And critics of such things as IBM's 360 and 370 computers would say that they are were Brobdingnagian, clumsy and surrounded by unnecessary difficulties.

And this of course is why many people like the kids who showed me around the University of Waterloo this morning far prefer to use systems like Digital Equipment machines which are much more accessible to the sophisticated user.

Anyway, the question is why has IBM prevailed in its way, and the answer is that they have a sort of monopoly. And one which obviously has a political side and a technical side. And the problem is now that as they are swinging their new communication system into place, it seems increasingly likely that this communication system is more built to maintain the monopoly than it is built to satisfy the needs of what people ought to have.

Q: What communication system?

A: Oh there's something called Satellite Business Systems, which IBM and Aetna Life Insurance and I think a few other partners have created in a joint venture.

Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by dluan on Saturday June 23, 2018 @08:06PM (#17384167)
The following short segment is great.

"What's swinging into place Max, is that we have great communication networks now coming about for the transmission of digital information.

Now by digital we just mean symbols. There's this mistake that digital means in numbers. That's wrong. The two commonest programming languages are musical notation and knitting instructions.

That's not fu... why are you laughing."

Knitting was really big back then.

Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by fapjacks on Saturday June 23, 2018 @09:33PM (#17384471)
Knitting is really big still. One of the biggest lobbies for copyright and IP legislation is (no kidding) the industry that creates patterns for sewing and knitting. Put out feelers on social media, see how many of your associates knit which you didn't know about. It was surprising to me for some reason to find out how pervasive it is.
Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by tomatotomato37 on Saturday June 23, 2018 @10:00PM (#17384541)
Wait, by sewing pattern industry, do you mean the fashion industry?
Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by fapjacks on Sunday June 24, 2018 @04:47AM (#17385647)
Haha that's a great question, but no, there is actually a different set of companies selling patterns for sewing and knitting (traditionally to their target demographic of older ladies). Companies that typically sell patterns to places like Hobby Lobby or Michaels, this kind of thing, and not companies like Old Navy and Forever21 and the like. In that industry, patterns are sort of like patents in a way, and these companies have amassed huge libraries of patterns and aggressively defend them with litigation. I'll dig a bit to see if I can find information about the specific events I'm thinking of, but the gist of it was that alongside Napster I believe, one of the biggest and earliest instances of copyright/IP litigation was against little old ladies who were using P2P to fileshare sewing and knitting patterns. This was before the RIAA started suing customers, and I believe it actually partly served as the inspiration for the RIAA stupidly choosing to go that route. It's been some years since I've read the story, so I'm likely not remembering some details correctly. Edit: I can't find a link to the story I'm thinking of, but you can actually find some side effects of this litigation, for example this "copyright notice" (especially read the actual PDF as this notice was pretty clearly issued to protect the interests of these pattern companies I'm talking about): https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/copyright-notice-...
Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by EGreg on Saturday June 23, 2018 @08:27PM (#17384253)
He forgot recipes :)
Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by thechao on Saturday June 23, 2018 @07:32PM (#17384047)
Brobdignagian is the opposite of Lilliputian—from Gulliver’s travels. It means stupendously gargantuan.
Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by JetSpiegel on Saturday June 23, 2018 @07:34PM (#17384055)
Brobdingnag is the "Gulliver's Travels"[1] country where everyone is a giant. Famous for having a breastfeeding woman horrifying the narrator, and him sword fighting a rat.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulliver%27s_Travels#Part_II:_...

Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by DonHopkins on Saturday June 23, 2018 @08:34PM (#17384284)
whoosh -- That's the second literary reference that went over my head when transcribing an interesting Ted Nelson video. I originally guessed he was saying that "Franklin Brouwer Zeus" invented the internet, when he actually said people thought "it sprang from the brow of Zeus". Here is the corrected version: ;)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edZgkNoLdAM

When we look at the past of computerdom, it's through a lens that's peculiar, because things have changed so much so fast.

That to me the 50 years since I've been in the computer field have gone so quickly that the past seems ever-present.

In the 60's and 70's, a lot of young people have started communes. And it was a combination of free love, which is a term you don't hear any more because it's taken for granted, and pot, and LSD, and idealism, and hope for a new kind of economy.

And that spirit of that age leaked into the computer world. There was a sense of possibility at the beginning that is different because we thought computing would be artisanal.

We did not imagine great monopolies. We thought the citizen programmer would be the leader.

When I say we I mean I, but of course I had a sense that I was sharing this with a lot of people.

We had visions of democratization, of citizen participation, to create vistas of possibility for artistic expression, and artistic expression in software. And software is an art form, though not generally recognized as such.

And because of Moore's Law, which has been stated to me not as Moore's Law, but just as a general principle: things will get faster and cheaper. We will be able to afford it. Right now a computer with a screen is $35,000. Tomorrow, who knows. It will be $100 some day.

Now is the time to start thinking about what will be the documents of the future.

As I would abstract it now, the two concepts were:

We can have parallel connections between visible documents. So you can have two pages with a connection saying "this sentence is connected to that paragraph" and see it as a visible strap or bridge.

And you can't do that yet. So that was one of my hypertext concepts.

And the other hypertext concept was being able to click on something and jump to it.

So as the hypertext concept developed and deteriorated over the years, only the jump link became popular in the hypertext systems of the 60's and the 70's, and then Tim Berners Lee created the World Wide Web, which was the sixth or seventh hypertext system on the internet.

People think it sprang from the brow of Zeus, in fact it was just a clean job that had the clout of CERN behind it. How to see the possibilities when there are so many things around you that are a certain way?

I don't know. The future is an unknown place. There are a lot of scary things about it.

What aspects you are going to approach? Are you going to go on thinking about leisure, or about the terrible problems that confront the world?

All I can say is: "Close your eyes, and think what might me."

My first software designs were largely done with my eyes closed. Thinking: "Now if I hit that key, what should happen? If it hit this key, what should happen?"

I was able to imagine -- they say this can't be done, but when my interfaces were built, they always felt the way I knew they would.

And the people at Xerox PARC said "That's never possible. You never know how it's going to be." But I did.

Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by TheTedNelson on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @01:51AM (#17406042)
Thanks for the transcription, but please change one word--

>All I can say is: "Close your eyes, and think what might me."

That last word should be "be".

(Apparently I also created a Ycombinator account under the name "Ted Nelson", but they won't tell me the password.)

Re:Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interview... by aportnoy on Saturday June 23, 2018 @07:34PM (#17384052)