News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by coldtea on Saturday June 23, 2018 @09:06AM (#17381094)
People genuinely have modest ambitions.

The "big ambitions" (and specifically, those not of the good kind, like e.g. becoming a doctor and such, but the "private pool", expensive car, lotsa money variety) have been shoehorned into the average American mind through over a century of indoctrination, advertisement, and propaganda.

It's all about making people never be content with their material belongings and thinking that the next purchase or achievement unlocked with make them happy.

E.g. https://www.amazon.com/Captains-Consciousness-Advertising-Co...

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by tntn on Saturday June 23, 2018 @10:10AM (#17381338)
> not of the good kind, like e.g. becoming a doctor

I would estimate that around 90% of the people I know who want to become a doctor (around 30 people) are motivated solely by the desire to make lotsa money and be able to drive an expensive car. Just saying, I don't think you can easily divide ambitions into "good" and "bad.

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by coldtea on Saturday June 23, 2018 @11:06AM (#17381582)
>I would estimate that around 90% of the people I know who want to become a doctor (around 30 people) are motivated solely by the desire to make lotsa money and be able to drive an expensive car.

There far easier ways to go about getting more money than spend over a decade in studying for it, plus all the hard work that comes afterwards.

More people that get into medicine that I know of either are idealistic, like the lifestyle (as portrayed on TV), had parents that were themselves doctors, or do it for the prestige. The money is not the biggest factor.

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by pimmen on Saturday June 23, 2018 @01:26PM (#17382283)
It’s not easy going into medicine but it is more reliable than many other paths.

In finance you can be very dependent on the market conditions, same in law (without a lot of business activity businesses don’t need to consult lawyers), in research you are also very dependent on the hype around your field to get grants, starting your own successful business is brutal if you don’t find the right opportunities or network of people, engineering is no cake walk of study either (especially adding in the work to stay relevant in the field) and joining a startup for good money is absolutely not a secure employment.

There will always be a need of medical personel however and since it requires a license given out by a few institutions you can be sure that your field will not be oversaturated, especially as it’s hard to obtain said license through study. Again, not saying it is easy becoming an MD, but if you are a competent person the path to a secure, good paying job is clearer if you choose med school than engineering, law, graduate or finance.

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by coldtea on Saturday June 23, 2018 @03:27PM (#17382938)
>It’s not easy going into medicine but it is more reliable than many other paths.

It is, but it also has a much smaller earnings cap than other professions. So "for the money" here means "for decent enough money but nothing to write home about".

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by pimmen on Saturday June 23, 2018 @06:40PM (#17383840)
I wouldn’t say that either, there are bio-tech startups you can join (only if you fail there’s a high paying job at the nearest hospital waiting for you) or you can climb within drug companies if you have the correct specialization to become an executive. I would say that’s analogous to becoming partner in the law world or a co-founder of a successful tech startup which is what money focused lawyers and engineers dream of respectively.

And depending on the country surgeons in specific fields can make obscene amounts of money. Neuro surgeons have a median salary of almost $600 000 in the US and to earn that much money as an engineer you have probably co-founded a successful startup or become an executive.

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by mantas on Sunday June 24, 2018 @12:37PM (#17387152)
Aren't most biotech or drug companies are probably looking for scientists in biology or chemistry. Not run-of-a-mill medical doctors. And becoming a 600k-worth neuro surgeon is probably as likely as running a decent startup, if not less.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by pimmen on Sunday June 24, 2018 @03:09PM (#17387878)
Never said becoming a median salaried neuro surgeon was more likely than running a decent startup but it is an argument against MDs having a smaller earnings cap than other professions.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by mantas on Saturday June 23, 2018 @10:20AM (#17381380)
I'd say good ambitions are those where you want X for X itself. If you want to be a doctor because you want love helping people - good. If you want to be a doctor just for $$$ - bad. If you want to become a singer because you love singing - good. If you want to be a singer just for $$$ - bad.

Old good "follow your passion"?

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by ahartmetz on Saturday June 23, 2018 @10:41AM (#17381457)
As long as X is a good thing - a few people want power just so they can hurt others...
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by Rexxar on Saturday June 23, 2018 @11:10AM (#17381605)
Not really. For example, a doctor who is here only for money can chose more expansive operation/treatment than necessary in order to win more even if it is not a good choice for the patient.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by alfredallan1 on Saturday June 23, 2018 @11:52AM (#17381793)
I think you might have nailed one of the more fundamental problems in US healthcare.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by mantas on Saturday June 23, 2018 @02:29PM (#17382629)
Well, seeking power to hurt others still falls in line with X for Y = bad...
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by meko on Saturday June 23, 2018 @06:35PM (#17383817)
it's almost like money makes things bad.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by moneytide on Saturday June 23, 2018 @10:47AM (#17381485)
Money is other people's time.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday June 23, 2018 @02:26PM (#17382618)
There was a comment here about someone who grew up in rural Africa and didn't have shoes, plumbing, etc. (the context was about chores being an indicator of future drive in children). He tellingly said he didn't feel underprivileged in his village as they were all in the same position; but IIRC when he moved to town his, and his siblings, expectations for basic necessities increased dramatically as they saw what others had. (I'm not sure he framed it like that. I may have erred).
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by mmsimanga on Saturday June 23, 2018 @02:56PM (#17382774)
That was probably me :-). You got the essence of my post correct. I was observing that human's wants, desires, aspirations seem to grow exponentially and as soon as you get what you wanted you want more. Yet back in the village my relatives have less, they want less and yet are less stressed than me the city dweller with more than them.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by johnsonjo on Saturday June 23, 2018 @06:11PM (#17383732)
I definitely agree with this sentiment. I lived in the Philippines for over a year and I was expecting the people to have the kind of sadness I would see in the commercials they sometimes show in the US for charities and such. In my first area, in the Phillipines, out in the rural boondocks I saw a lot of poverty, but I also saw a surprisingly large amount of happiness and a deep community atmosphere.

The people were so kind and thoughtful. I didn’t ask them about their aspirations all that often, but they often seemed content with their life as it was. Every once in a while you would get someone who had higher ambitions e.g. those who wanted to move out into the city.

Seeing their contentment and the time I spent there helped me realize that happiness doesn’t need to come from material things and having more than everyone else. I feel American culture has often tried to teach me otherwise. Sad.

Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday June 24, 2018 @09:18AM (#17386429)
Yes it was! My short term memory isn't always reliable but glad if I got the gist right -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17373062 was your comment I was referencing for those following along at home.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by spiralx on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @07:17AM (#17399553)
It's more that human's judge their status relative to their peers, not by any absolute scale - so despite having more absolute wealth after moving to the city, their status relative to everyone else is far lower than it was back in their village.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by kodablah on Saturday June 23, 2018 @10:49AM (#17381496)
Strange to think by nature my modest ambitions are genuine but I have been nurtured out of them by external forces. I suppose thinking this way would preclude one from seeing that ambition is primarily self driven (regardless of size or subjective definitions of "good").
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by coldtea on Saturday June 23, 2018 @03:28PM (#17382949)
Well, animals in nature (which evolutionary, we still are, civilization is just a tiny sliver of time) don't really have ambitions.
Re:Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions... by kodablah on Saturday June 23, 2018 @04:25PM (#17383264)
Disagree. Like humans, some have high ambitions and some don't. This is why there are leaders.