Re:How an Engineering Company Chose to Migrate to D
by JdeBP on Friday June 22, 2018 @10:13AM
(#17374081)
That is not in fact true.
ENTER copies M words from the caller's stack frame. The pointer passed by MetaWare High C/C++ in the register could equally well have been placed at the relevant position in the caller's stack frame, just as other arguments are, and an ENTER N,1 used as part of the perilogue.
The only consideration here is speed of the ENTER instruction versus having the hidden pointer in a register, not that this sort of nested function implementation is somehow impossible with ENTER. It's just another case of ENTER is slow and other instructions do the same thing better.
ENTER copies M words from the caller's stack frame. The pointer passed by MetaWare High C/C++ in the register could equally well have been placed at the relevant position in the caller's stack frame, just as other arguments are, and an ENTER N,1 used as part of the perilogue.
The only consideration here is speed of the ENTER instruction versus having the hidden pointer in a register, not that this sort of nested function implementation is somehow impossible with ENTER. It's just another case of ENTER is slow and other instructions do the same thing better.
* http://jdebp.info./FGA/function-perilogues.html#Standardx86
(Part of that consideration is making non-nested functions usable via full function pointers.)