Re:Particle physics experiments have stopped answering to gr...
by lokimedes on Thursday June 21, 2018 @05:35PM
(#17369495)
I tend to agree (as an ex particle physicist who spent 8 years hunting for hypothetical supersymmetrical particles at the LHC), but to be honest what works is the scientific method and that requires both blind evidence and theory driven falsification to produce new knowledge.
In particle physics we switched paradigm after the invention of QCD and the electroweak theories, and now it’s difficult getting back to pure discovery driven research as the risk seems too high to both sponsors and researchers.
Also, theory first is barely working nowadays too. The entire field has a problem, and that problem looks much more like "all the easy problems are solved already" than "we must think things through before testing them".
Anyway, I do agree that experiment-first is much harder to sell. People dig for a good looking theory, even if it's worthless.