News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Real v. Imagined wealth distribution in the US by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @02:00PM (#1736592)
Wealth inequality is not the only thing that can lead to social instability. Angry mobs have formed and engaged in violence over many issues - interracial sexual relationships in the US (historically) and conversion from Islam in Afghanistan are two such examples.

If one advocates against wealth inequality on the grounds that angry mobs might engage in violence if inequality were too large, shouldn't one also advocate against X whenever there is a significant risk of violence by mobs?

If policy should cater to angry mobs threatening violence on issues of wealth inequality, should policy cater to angry mobs on issues of racial hatred or religious conflict as well?

Re:Real v. Imagined wealth distribution in the US by jtbigwoo on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @03:02PM (#1736811)
I would argue that economic instability was a strong contributor to the racial and religious violence you describe. It's easier to tune out intolerance when you're secure in your station.
Re:Real v. Imagined wealth distribution in the US by yummyfajitas on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @03:14PM (#1736865)
Southern white men were not secure in their station during the 50's and earlier?

Regardless, you are ducking the meta question. Is "a mob might become violent if we don't do X" a good argument for doing X? I.e., if angry racist mobs start rioting over a black president, should we impeach Obama? Should we engage in appeasement, paying each racist $500 to go home (perhaps levying a tax on blacks to pay for it)? Similarly, should we ban criticism of Christianity if Christians form lynch mobs of their own?

Which angry violent mobs should we surrender to?