Nowadays, mostly being rich means you get a bigger chair on the airplane, a bunch of rooms in your house that you pay to heat but never go into, a car that requires more fuel, and if you got your money faster than sense, the idiotic practice of gold plating ordinary objects and gluing diamonds all over them.
This can change if the lack of wealth once again has the potential to threaten life. With the way we are cavalierly poking the health care beast, its not that difficult to imagine. If parents are ever told in a way that makes it clear to them that their sick children will be denied treatment that could save their lives because of a lack of money (that a richer person would think nothing of wasting on a weekend in Vegas), class warfare once again becomes a possibility.
People vote and support policy based on how their perceptions. It's important to understand what those perceptions are.
Isn't it more akin to showing programmers those source code listings, and then being appalled that so many got it wrong? We're talking about asking the relevant people who make decisions: programmers should know the facts about algorithms, or else it's likely they will make poor choices when writing software; and voters should know the facts about their society/economy/etc., or else it's likely they will make poor choices when voting.
I'm not sure you have a full appreciation of the extent of poverty in contemporary U.S... The official US Government definition of poverty is (according to Wikipedia):
The "absolute poverty line" is the threshold below which families or individuals are considered to be lacking the resources to meet the basic needs for healthy living; having insufficient income to provide the food, shelter and clothing needed to preserve health.
Wikipedia claims that in 2008, 40 million people (13%) met that definition.
Given the fact that the US needs a huge part of the resources of the rest of the world (labor, oil, etc.) in order to be "rich" by whatever definition, it's kind of cheating to exclude the rest of the world's population from your argument on the distribution of wealth.
Marx may have only been wrong about time and scale...
They didn't revolt when they were poor, why should they start now?
Also, I didn't exclude anyone - the article is very explicitly about wealth distribution in the US.
There are legions of people working 80 hours a week to put a bowl of soup on their own table and televisions on the tables of the American poor.
This one is too good. Can I use it?
first of all, THAT is a giant strawman.
and second, so that's your justification for less equality - "be glad you weren't born in 20s!"?
maybe you heard about "American Dream" and stuff...
The way I read this passage of the Declaration is twofold:
A. In the eyes of the law (that is, the only way that the government can view us), all men enjoy the same rights, privileges, and protections.
B. We are clearly diverse; it is obvious that no two of us are exactly alike, or in any way interchangeable. However, it's not possible to assign a value to those differences. The way each of us fit into the grand scheme of society is far too complex to tease apart.
[1] About: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Harrison_Berg... ; Text: http://www.nationalreview.com/nroriginals/?q=MDllNmVmNGU1NDV...
0) either there is 100% inequality (which is where America seems to be headed now)
1) or there is 100% equality (that previous commenter likens to nuclear war)
That seems to me to stem from polarisation of those issues by American media: you're either rich hard working patriotic american or muslim terrorist commie.
No wonder you get the same partisan politics in Parliament and Obamas and Palins as leaders.
Well, in my world aka ROW there are larger inequalities and there are smaller inequalities and when the pendulum swings too much in one direction it's time for society to rethink something, not engage in witch hunt.
Anyway, this whole topic is too tiresome by now. After all it's called American Dream, not European or Asian Dream. Go figure it out for yourselves!
In the beginning of the 20th century, class warfare was apparently imminent, but the difference between now and then isn't wealth distribution, it's wealth - period. Being poor then meant worrying about whether or not you could shelter and feed your family, today and tomorrow, not to mention over the winter, and the way to do that was more often than not through long hours of backbreaking work that might very well kill you. Being poor today means worrying about an entirely different, and much more comfortable, set of issues.
And that's just being poor, not even thinking about life in the second and third quintile.
The rich got extremely rich, while the poor got very rich. Life in general became much cheaper, safer and more comfortable. I'm sure you could find plenty of fifth-quintile people in 1915 who'd be happy to switch life with first quintile people anno 2010.
And the short version: Marx was wrong about a lot of stuff. Let's quit being surprised when reality doesn't fit Das Kapital.