Also, keep in mind that it isn't all asylum applicants who get separated. If you show up at a valid port of entry into the US and request asylum, then no crime has been committed and no one is separated from their families. Only people who sneak across the border illegally(which is a crime) are processed from their criminal behavior.
Going to a valid port of entry also happens to be a much cheaper and safer way of getting to America, considering it doesn't require the use of human mules, paying exorbitant fees and coordinating with drug cartels, and performing dangerous desert crossings where you may get abandoned if your mule gets spooked.
edit: alasdair_, I can't comment on your post thanks to HN aggressively preventing a poster responding to numerous comments on a post, but I would imagine the reason that she couldn't file an asylum claim is right in the article: Because she lied about being a US citizen in the past, and that bars you from presenting for asylum. And finally, the father separated himself from his children before he even entered the US, because he knew he couldn't enter the US because he was already deported from the US in the past.
> Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials say Maria made a false claim of US citizenship in 1999 and served a 75-day sentence in a federal prison before being deported back to Guatemala at that time. In a statement provided to CNN, ICE says that lying about citizenship status "results in a permanent bar from being able to legally enter the United States."
Yet, somehow, having what is essentially a concentration camp of kids isn't the president going too far and being sick.
There is in my mind zero justification for the current state of things and I don't care what argument is used to try to claim there is.
I don't plan to participate further in this discussion. I think I have made all the comments I can make while complying with HN guidelines. This situation is just beyond the pale for me.
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/photo/2018/06/photos-a-tent-city...
The child will end up in a temporary foster home or similar housing. They will not be kept in locked chain-link areas for weeks on end.
>Also, keep in mind that it isn't all asylum applicants who get separated. If you show up at a valid port of entry into the US and request asylum, then no crime has been committed and no one is separated from their families.
This is flat out wrong.
See (for example - there are many other documented cases) https://www.cnn.com/2018/06/05/us/guatemalan-immigrant-famil...
"After the rest of the family took their chances by presenting themselves to US immigration authorities, the possibility of forced separation became reality. The 20-year-old son was sent to a detention center in San Diego. Maria and her three youngest children were shipped to a family detention center in Dilley, Texas -- about 70 miles southwest of San Antonio."
"The two youngest members of the Villatoro family are now at a detention center in New York state while their mom remains detained in Texas."
Sneaking across the border is a crime but its a misdemeanor like driving without a seatbelt or ignoring a "No Trespassing" sign. It's very rare for people to be thrown in jail while awaiting trials for misdemeanors and generally the consequence of committing a single one isn't jail time.
So US policy at the border, while legal, is horribly unreasonable and maliciously cruel.
I love your point about sneaking across the border. Those supporters of the current regime's policy, some 25-30% of the polled US population, will often simply state that these are law-breakers and criminals for breaking our laws. And yet, is the same opprobrium applied to those who speed, shoot off fireworks illegally, or dodge taxes (like many of the rich today)? If they were truly about law and order, rather than about an othering/discriminatory scheme, surely they would decry these other violations of the law?
Generally people don't support this. Therefore, downvotes.
However, arresting and prosecuting every single person who crosses the border in a nominally illegal way[1] is not a norm, and neither is deporting parents while their children are still being held in the US.
[1]: "Nominally" because many of the current cases involve asylum seekers who have been cut off from actually seeking asylum.
Besides, ethics are more important than laws.
Source: http://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/us-immigration/crime-ent...
The organization also says that in some cases, the children were taken away under the pretense that they would be getting a bath.
From an article about the current US practice of separating children, including infants, from their parents at the border:
https://www.npr.org/2018/06/19/621065383/what-we-know-family...