News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by krschultz on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @08:58AM (#1735517)
FreeOffice wasn't an option?

Open Source Office?

Anything-other-than-LibreOffice?

OpenOffice is something that I can explain to my mother when I install it for her instead of MS Office, Mom, it's just like Office but it is open source. In fact she didn't notice for a long time.

Libre Office? She'll question that for sure, and then what am I going to do, explain the GNU manifesto to her? Come on.

I like the use of the word Libre instead of Free among people who know what we're talking about, but from a marketing/branding standpoint, this is horrible.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by nihilocrat on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:29AM (#1735597)
"Libre" is probably better understood in Europe to mean "free" in its intended "free as in speech" sense.
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by krschultz on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:48AM (#1735649)
That is probably true in Europe, but it definitely fails in the US. What I don't see is why the name has to be so damn literal.

Firefox was never named "Libre Interent Browser"

Google was never "Better Search Engine That Doesn't Totally Suck"

OpenOffice at least wasn't that clunky and got the point across.

This is a name by hackers for hackers. Why is that a good idea for a project with the mainstream reach of Firefox? This is a cross platform office suite, it could be used by literally EVERY PERSON WHO USES A COMPUTER, the name is extremely important. It doesn't have to mention a damn thing about open source, free software, or anything in its name. Most people don't care about Firefox's development model - they just like using it. OpenOffice should be the same way.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by sprout on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @11:32AM (#1735975)
Yes, and who wants to use a game console that sounds like a man's genitals or a tablet computer that sounds like a menstruation guard. Names do not matter when you already have a product people want and need.
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by krschultz on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @12:05PM (#1736116)
I assume you mean the (Sony) PlayStation and the (Apple) iPad.

What sticks out to you there? If you don't see the vast difference between the Sony or Apple brand and the Libre Office brand then you don't understand marketing.

At this point Steve Jobs could make a toilet called the iShit and people would not care about the name, because they know and love the Apple brand. The product names matter extremely little for them, because people hear Apple (some bad product name), not (some unknown company) iPad. People are excited for the former and ridicule the later.

Sony holds an equally good name with many.

Both also have massive TV advertising budgets.

There is no comparison to this situation.

Explain why FOSS is often times better than the commercial counter point and is by definition cheaper, but still isn't gaining traction, what is the problem?

I contend the problem is marketing. FOSS developers love to redicule/ignore marketing, advertising, and business people in general, but it is an important part of gaining mindshare. Sure their degree is easier to get, but that doesn't mean their job is easy to do right. Much like the bike shed, everyone has an opinion on marketing and advertising, that doesn't mean they have a good opinion on it. Saying that Apple and Sony are in anyway relevent to the naming of a relatively unknown product by a new group of people is like a marketing guy saying Cobol on Cogs is just like Ruby on Rails. We'd laugh at the marketing guy, but realize the marketing guys are laughing right back at the devs who suck at selling FOSS. We literally can't give away for free what they are charging money for.

You know where fixing that problem starts? By respecting marketing and advertising. It is far more than "just a name". There is no such thing as "just a name" when your only method of spreading the word is by word of mouth

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by calloc on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @01:04PM (#1736339)
Actually, I think he was referring to the Wii ...
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by juanefren on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @01:37PM (#1736475)
Even for Spanish speaking people it is a slow pronunciation word, Even OfficeLibre would be easier to pronounce.
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by sandGorgon on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @01:28PM (#1736425)
true - it is going to especially troublesome for non-native English speakers, who wont be able to pronounce the name.

Especially in Asia - is it "lee-bree office" or "lie-bree office" ?

Even worse is that you cant use the word in spoken conversation, and hope they will be able to spell it correctly enough for Google to work.

They are gonna search for "libr office" - which returns Microsoft Office as the top hit. Which means I cant go and ask my friends to download it.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by alextgordon on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:50AM (#1735659)
"Libre" also sounds exactly the same as "Libra". Maybe they should call it StarOffice :)
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by patrickaljord on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @03:22PM (#1736901)
> OpenOffice is something that I can explain to my mother when I install it for her instead of MS Office, Mom, it's just like Office but it is open source.

In what way is open source easy to explain? Are you going to tell your mom that software is made up of source code that needs to be compiled and OpenOffice gives access to that source? It's much simpler to say Libre as in Freedom because you can do whatever you want with the software, modify, redistribute, resell etc

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by jawee on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:11AM (#1735552)
Isn't it easier to explain the concept of libre meaning free[dom] than it is to explain the concept of open source, which may be harder to grasp? If you need to explain, libre is similar to liberty.. and it's a word in several languages.

I fail to see how it's a marketing failure.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by dminor on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @11:37AM (#1735991)
> I fail to see how it's a marketing failure.

Because it's awkward to pronounce and then you have try to explain it. Ideally a name would be easy to read and pronounce, and self-describing, and LibreOffice fails on both counts.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by hakl on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:03AM (#1735528)
Did you explain to her what source code is and explain OSI's definition of open source (you know, DFSG rebranded)?
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by blasdel on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:47AM (#1735647)
And after that he can explain how the freedom is really for the source code and not for her!
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by rbanffy on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @10:32AM (#1735787)
Not really. If it's GPL, it's freedom for her from the developer.
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by gaius on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @12:58PM (#1736309)
Assuming she has both the skill and the time to understand and patch the codebase herself. Otherwise she will be just as beholden to said developer as she is to Microsoft.

More in fact; at least MS has some incentive to add features its users want rather than those that are merely interesting to code...

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by rbanffy on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @01:42PM (#1736503)
> Otherwise she will be just as beholden to said developer as she is to Microsoft.

She can buy a book and learn how to bend the program to her will. It may be a daunting task, but it's possible because she has the source code. In the Microsoft product case, she can't because she doesn't have the source.

Actually, she can, but she will have to learn how to program, apply for a job opening at Microsoft for the desired group, get hired and then convince the product manglers the change she wants deserves to be included in the product.

Reading the book doesn't seem that daunting now.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by gaius on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @02:04PM (#1736607)
Oh please! How many months, or years perhaps, working at it every day, would it take a normal, not-particularly technical end-user to get their C++ to a level they could add meaningful features to a full blown office suite? Or at a typical hourly rate, how much would it cost to hire a C++ programmer who's never seen this code before to do it, and how long would it take? Weeks probably.

You might as well say, there are books in the library, go build a rocket and fly to the moon.

But users, collectively, can decide what feature any commercial organization implements next, by indicating what they are willing to pay for.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by patrickaljord on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @03:30PM (#1736930)
She could just pay someone to hack on the code for her, not something she could do with MS Office.
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by gaius on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @04:04PM (#1737049)
At the hourly rate of a decent C++ hacker, that will cost more than Microsoft's entire product range at retail...

There is an entire industry of VB and VBA programmers who customize MS Office for organizations. I gather even OpenOffice.org has some of that capability. But to do something to OOo that you can't do in VBA with MS Office is a substantial amount of work.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by rbanffy on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @04:17PM (#1737109)
> Oh please! How many months, or years perhaps, working at it every day, would it take a normal, not-particularly technical end-user to get their C++ to a level they could add meaningful features to a full blown office suite?

OOo plug-ins don't need to be developed in C++

http://wiki.services.openoffice.org/wiki/Extensions_developm...

And it also depends on what you call meaningful. And then, you are completely ignoring every other person who shares the same problem and that can cooperate in solving it - or hiring someone for that.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by gaius on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @04:39PM (#1737213)
Like, umm, a commercial software company?

Look, this is about power. In the commercial world, the power ultimately, albeit indirectly, lies in the hands of the end user who decide what he or she will and will not pay for. In the "free software" world the power is in the hands of the high priests who are beholden to no-one, and users are expected to be grateful for whatever they're given.

Do you think the average user wouldn't want something for free? But the cost can't be avoided in software - it only depends what currency you want to pay in.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by rbanffy on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @05:12PM (#1737338)
> Like, umm, a commercial software company?

Just hire them and demand their work to be licensed to you under a free license.

Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by hakl on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @01:05PM (#1736348)
The source code inanimate. The GNU manifesto says that users shouldn't have arbitrary restrictions imposed on them; this has individual and collective implications.
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by rick_2047 on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:43AM (#1735637)
Its just a name, will she really makes a fuss out of it?
Re:LibreOffice - A fresh page for OpenOffice by borism on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @11:46AM (#1736037)
of course not, it's just something to whine about on the internet forums, that's all.