News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by ComputerGuru on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @05:52AM (#1735132)
...and people ask me why I write tons of freeware, but make so little of it open source.

The reason is simple: control. If I can't control every stage of the development, deployment, and distribution process, I don't want in (yes, I'm a control freak. No, I don't think necessarily a blemish on my personality, it's just who I am). If there's something wrong with how my users perceive my software, it's because of something _I_ did wrong, not because someone took my hard work and toil and perverted it with their own changes, be it making the code ugly with nasty function names or dirty hacks (in my opinion, of course) or if they distribute it in a way that makes users cringe. It's my hard work, and I deserve to be (a) in control of the user experience, and (b) attributed.

If you're willing to make your awesome utility/code that you've spent 5 years developing and maintaining fully available to the public, giving up all control of the end-users' perception of the package, you have a bigger heart than me. But me, I'm a selfish guy when it comes to my users, and I don't want anyone to even have the possibility of hurting them. I have _my_ users' best interest at heart, you probably don't. At least, not to the same extent that I would.

Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by VMG on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @06:07AM (#1735156)
You could still make it open source but craft the license in a way to prevent redistribution
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by davidw on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @06:08AM (#1735157)
> You could still make it open source but craft the license in a way to prevent redistribution

Then it would not be open source.

Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by narag on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @06:34AM (#1735203)
There are certain clauses that don't affect the definition of a program as open source, but would prevent it to be included by, let's say, Debian. I'm thinking on the old BSD license or the branding problem of Firefox.
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by davidw on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @06:37AM (#1735211)
Debian includes the Firefox code, though. You can certainly say "you can redistribute my code, but not call it XYZ if you've modified it", that still lies within the realm of open source.
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by narag on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:19AM (#1735565)
That was my point. It's open source and still it's not distributed under the Firefox brand, so users won't fill bugs in Mozilla's bugtrack.
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by VMG on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @06:53AM (#1735245)
Right, though I didn't mean the capitalized Open Source but "you can still share the source code" and thereby still accept patches for example. You could also allow forks as long as they use a different name that your project.
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by rmc on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @07:25AM (#1735296)
If you allow forks under a different name, then someone will put it into Linux distros with that name. Just look at Firefox/IceWeasel. Or CentOS
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by kleiba on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @06:19AM (#1735179)
Of course it would, but it would not be free software.
Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by davidw on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @06:21AM (#1735182)
"open source" has a precise definition, and doesn't just mean "you get the source code":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Source_Definition

Re:Making Debian Responsible For Its Actions by kleiba on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @09:08AM (#1735547)
I guess my wording wasn't the best. My point was that source code which is available, but only under a non-permissive license, would certainly not be considered free.

Some people, first and foremost rms, dismiss the term "open source" completely for missing the point.

http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-software-for-freedom.html

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSZZraHN0Yg