News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Pound of Flesh by jessriedel on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @04:39AM (#1735000)
This author is confused about the meaning of "don't be evil". He seems to think it means to conform to a particular morality (i.e., the one to which the author subscribes) in all aspects of business. He probably thinks this is supported by the fact that Google embraces various left-leaning causes (investing in geothermal energy, etc.) when it's not clear that this could be justified in a business sense by the good publicity it generates.

But I think the original meaning of "don't be evil" is much more modest. It means: don't betray the trust of the user. For example, don't sell SEO favors, don't sell the user's info to advertisers, don't trick the user into downloading anything, don't abuse a monopoly position, etc. (This isn't to say that Google hasn't bent/broken these rules.) The fact that Google also supports various left-leaning causes is just a reflection of the fact that an unusually small number of left-leaning people influence the company's decisions.

I think the wikipedia article supports this interpretation.

I really don't think "don't be evil" has anything to do with a particular ideology which might disapprove of pay-day loans or whatever.

Re:Google’s Pound of Flesh by gaius on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @08:02AM (#1735384)
Actually all it means is "we see our main competitor as Microsoft".
Re:Google’s Pound of Flesh by Robin_Message on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @10:13AM (#1735726)
There aren't many ideologies that accept pay-day loans as anything other than evil frankly, so it's not one particular ideology that disapproves of pay-day loans, it's all of them. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usury and note that a pay-day loan is exactly the kind of loan that is usurious — anyone who takes one hasn't got the money they need to make it to the end of the month, i.e. their outgoings are more than their incomings. They will never be able to pay such a debt off.

This is not a business I would have thought Google wants to get into, not because of the evil nature of it, but simply because making money from it legally is logically impossible.

Re:Google’s Pound of Flesh by jessriedel on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @03:14PM (#1736867)
I don't think we'll settle an argument here, but I'll say this: The large majority of payday loans are repaid. So long as (1) the borrowers are well informed and (2) there is healthy competition between the loaners, payday loans are good for society. They allow people who otherwise wouldn't get credit to float over rough patches.

Let me ask you this. If you are poor and living month-to-month, and your uninsured car--which you need to get to work to continue earning money--is wrecked, what do you do? Not everyone has families to help them in this situation.