Re:Facebook ordered to explain deleted profile
by jnbiche on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @03:42PM
(#17349706)
Sorry, but if you're not family it next-of-kin, and you requested for Facebook to delete someone's profile, you should be identified to their family, and the profile restored.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Facebook ordered to explain deleted profile
by crysin on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @03:45PM
(#17349725)
What if you have power of attorney? Even if you were family, Facebook should not be help responsible for having to provide you with a name. The person who made the request has a right to their privacy and if Facebook acted in good-faith (which is questionable, I know) and validated the person making the request had the right to do so then I don't see any issue with Facebook's actions so far.
Re:Facebook ordered to explain deleted profile
by barkingcat on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @03:59PM
(#17349847)
That's what the court order is about - determining whether Facebook acted in good faith, or whether there was a process for determining power of attorney.
You even said that whole point was questionable - enough of a question to have a court legally compel Facebook to answer these questions.
I don't see any issues with the court case pressing forward to get some answers, do you?
Re:Facebook ordered to explain deleted profile
by jnbiche on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @05:29PM
(#17350422)
OK, next-of-kin and/or power of attorney, I should have added. Yes, I agree. I'm sure the court would, as well.
But not some random person, fan, or acquaintance, as it appears in this case.
Re:Facebook ordered to explain deleted profile
by notahacker on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @06:42PM
(#17350875)
Even assuming their action was purely malicious (and not, say, an extended family member or friend or even fan of the band that was a bit surprised to see a still active profile for someone they were well aware was no longer around and thought they were fixing things), it's a weird world where Facebook has some sort of moral duty to disclose their identity to people apparently obsessed with pursuing them.
If the profile can't be restored, that sounds like a separate policy issue with Facebook defaulting to permanently deleting rather than simply hiding profiles in these circumstances.