Unfortunately, people who need such loans often default, resulting in high interest rates. Also unfortunate is that many people live their lives in a state of near-constant emergency. But what can you do? The constancy of their emergencies doesn't make them any less bad.
By extension, any time you pay 50% more on the price of something in order to have it one day sooner (cough medicine at a convenience store, food at an amusement park, etc.) you're getting it at an APR in excess of 10 to the 60th power.
Edit: the company you are borrowing from will be borrowing the money they lend to you at probably 10 - 15% APR (in the UK). That's quite a spread.
The right way to look at loans is to break them down into APR and default risk multiplier. The total amount which needs to be paid back is DRM x exp(APR x duration). Payday loans, much like the racetrack, have reasonable APR's but high DRM's.
Dividing ln(DRM) by small numbers is as ridiculous as dividing a $1 investment by 1/1 billion % of a company and claiming that 37 signals has a $100 billion valuation. Yeah, they are using a standard formula, but in a ridiculous way. Models are pointless when you use them beyond their range of validity.
http://37signals.com/svn/posts/1941-press-release-37signals-...
I don't think this business is a licence to print money, the various providers must be competing with each other...
This is not an excuse for predatory practice. By this metric, there is a market for crack, why would you despise honest crack dealers, they're simply satisfying their customers after all.
I believe the role of government should be to protect me from other people, not from myself.
If I want to buy crack, and someone wants to sell me crack, you shouldn't be able to stand in my way. If I want to take out a short term loan a a high percentage rate, Cringely shouldn't be able to stand in my way.
I don't want a third party eliminating choice from my life just because a hypothetical victim may exist. I'm an adult of sound mind, and will make my own decisions.
However, this doesn't mean that I would feel okay about selling you crack myself, or that I think highly of people who are willing to sell you crack.
One can agree that something is undesirable or even evil without thinking it should be illegal, and yeah, personally, I think that both encouraging another person to use a highly addictive substance and profiting from usurious loans are "evil" acts, even though I don't think either one should be illegal.
Those companies and the people that actually make use of their services, of course. This author might not have noticed, but generally markets for things no one wants don't exist.
It's tempting to view loans that are typically paid back quickly in terms of an APR, but it's extremely deceptive. The reason the annual rate is so high is that, surprise, people who can't plan their budget out more than a few days in advance are also not generally the best at paying loans back on time (or at all.) And viewed in raw amounts, paying an extra few dollars a week from now for milk today isn't the worst deal in the world, if it keeps the kids fed.