News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log in pages

I have a uservoice account, where I administer the help site for Windy Citizen. Today, I decided I wanted to sign in to check/update the settings I have on it. I click the "sign in" button on the uservoice front page and get this:

http://uservoice.com/signin

It's asking me for an e-mail and a username. Nowhere does it ask me for a password.

I've been thinking about this form for about 5 minutes, and I'm still not 100% sure how I'm supposed to use it. Do I enter in one? The other? I've been clicking around trying to find a password field somewhere so I can log into the account I set up.

Developers, please don't screw with stuff like this.

( 8 comments | 17 points | on HN )
Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by SHOwnsYou on Monday September 27, 2010 @07:38PM (#1733969)
It likely auto-generates one and sends it to your email.

This is a good lesson on usability if you (I assume pretty internet-literate) are thrown by this. Very important to note this error.

Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by vyrotek on Monday September 27, 2010 @07:40PM (#1733975)
I have to agreed, it confused me as well a few weeks ago.

When I have a task or goal in mind on a site the last thing I want to do is tinker and figure out your new way to log in.

Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by uptown on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @04:54PM (#1737279)
I'm curious what the general consensus is for using something like OAuth for authentication for sites with a non-technical focus. Personally, the login form implementation of StackOverflow is perfect. But I wonder whether asking people to log in using the credentials from another site is still a confusing concept if a portion of your userbase is non-technical.
Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by lukevdp on Monday September 27, 2010 @10:12PM (#1734314)
If you enter your email, if it's an email that has signed up, the name field turns into a password field. I agree it's very confusing when trying it for the first time. I also imagine that there are a lot of duplicate accounts around, I know I have a few
Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by DevX101 on Monday September 27, 2010 @07:59PM (#1734039)
Send them a link to this thread
[deleted]
Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by brandnewlow on Monday September 27, 2010 @07:43PM (#1733985)
I did.

I haven't logged int uservoice in a few months. So I was half guessing at my e-mail address and username.

Normally, when I don't remember, the error prompts on the log in page will indicate if I'm trying the wrong creds. Then I can try another set of creds.

But on this form, instead of telling me my creds didn't match anyone, it registered a new account with the e-mail address and username I entered and auto-sent me an e-mail welcoming me to uservoice. Ugh.

I tried it again with a different e-mail address, this time it matched the e-mail address against one in its DB and changed the username field into a password field before I could enter something into the username field. I took this change as an indicate that I'd found the proper e-mail address, entered in my password and was logged in. The whole experience was confusing and annoying though, almost as bad as the whole OpenID click-hear-go-to-another-site-read-some-legal-stuff-click-there-go-back-to-original site UX disaster.

Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by captaincrowbar on Monday September 27, 2010 @08:55PM (#1734180)
So anyone can enter an email address and find out immediately whether it corresponds to a valid account, without having to enter a password or anything else?

Security FAIL.

Re:Tell HN: Developers please don't do anything weird on log... by motocycle on Tuesday September 28, 2010 @08:41AM (#1735463)
Agree. But alas this is pretty common nowadays.. Try Groupon's login page, you'll get email address not found error with any unregistered email addresses