News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eugene Debs Was Jailed for Speaking Out Against WWI, 100 ... by arethuza on Monday June 18, 2018 @10:49AM (#17338644)
To be fair to the small number of posh people I've known who have been in the British Army they all had led troops on the ground - probably desperately trying to live up to the reputations of their ancestors at Waterloo/Culloden/Hastings...
Re:Eugene Debs Was Jailed for Speaking Out Against WWI, 100 ... by Brockenstein on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:05PM (#17339307)
Well there's a lot of caveats to this depending on how you're defining "posh people" to the previous ideas of aristocracy and nobility of the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

I mean one of the big ones is that WWI was atrocious for infantry because the tactics were 19th century, but the weapons were 20th century. IE generals were fighting the war like there weren't machines guns, chemical weapons and a laundry list of revolutionary developments that made outdated tactics just devastating.

A lot of wars have been fought since then and our tactics have adjusted quite a bit. Which means we're generally not sending wave after wave of men into entrenched enemy fortifications and railing about their cowardice when those assaults fail or saluting their "heroism" when those units are wiped out to the man.

We've got better protection and better medical care leading to higher survivability. We're not in a state of total war, and we're not anywhere near close to talking about lost generations from current conflicts.

Probably most of the posh people you know came back whole. Well that didn't always happen and amount of risk certainly tempers many peoples decisions about whether to serve in the military if they have options.

And frankly given a choice between serving in the darkest days of WW1 and a current conflict wouldn't be a tough choice for many soldiers.

Re:Eugene Debs Was Jailed for Speaking Out Against WWI, 100 ... by arethuza on Monday June 18, 2018 @12:22PM (#17339449)
Ah - I'm from the UK so "posh" in this context to me means traditional very upper middle class or lower upper class. Definitely not posh as in spice.