"Deutsche Bank and Barclays used the options structure to open accounts for their clients in their own names, creating the illusion that they owned the assets. But in fact, the hedge funds exercised complete control over the assets, executed all the trades and raked in all of the trading profits, according to the report.
The hedge funds exercised the options soon after the one-year mark and claimed that the trading profits were eligible for the 20 percent (previously 15 percent) tax rate that applies to long-term capital gains on assets held for at least a year. The report contends that those options were actually short-term trades that should have been taxed at the ordinary income rate of 39 percent, which would otherwise apply to investors in hedge funds engaged in daily trading" [1].
Market makers are taxed differently from other investors. Certain market makers tried to "rent" their low-tax status to hedge funds. All this resulted from a weird 1999 law trying to fix a loophole in some other arcane law [2].
Last I heard, the IRS charged the market makers for the investors' short-term gains [3], and did so retroactively.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/senate-repor...
[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-07-03/the-irs-c...
[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/09/business/dealbook/irs-cra...
The IRS’s wording suggests that other funds may have also been improperly using basket options. I’m admittedly not even close to being a tax law expert so I can’t really offer much more analysis
I’m pretty sure I was wrong that the taxes were being used as arbitrage, though. The allegedly unpaid taxes seem to be based on payments out of the fund to employees