News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by codingdave on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:43AM (#17331959)
Or... first get the team to acknowledge the problem and agree that a fix is needed. Then have everyone research solutions. Propose your tool while asking what other solutions have been found. As a team, talk about the pros/cons of each option, and facilitate those discussions. Build consensus by listening and understanding what your team has to say. Once you agree on the solution, talk through the configuration questions. Then talk through a deployment and adoption plan.

Because if you just want the problem fixed, then it isn't an issue of manipulating corporate politics to support your lead... it is an issue of working together to come up with a shared solution.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by lkrubner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:19AM (#17332054)
But my co-workers might have strong emotional attachments to answers that I know are wrong. I might have a co-worker who promotes their favorite technology as the answer to all problems. I might already know, from previous battles, that particular people are going to distort the conversation in particular ways. If I'm going to go into a situation without trying to push a particular agenda, I'd have to be willing to let the wrong choice be made.
Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by ozim on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:35AM (#17332308)
Yes and the biggest possible win you can make is to let go off your own "good solution". Beeing humble and dealing with problems later in lieu of beeing always right is correct choice.

You have to prevent only catastrophic decisions.

If you are working on CRUD web platform most decisions will not be catastrophic. Maybe inconvenient, maybe eat more budget but probably company will not go under because of some technical decision.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by darkerside on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:34AM (#17332518)
Catastrophic decisions are rarely as bad as they sound. You lose time and resources resolving them, maybe lose some customers, and possibly even data. Yes, this sucks. You also learn a valuable lesson. This makes your team stronger.

Much worse is a series of mediocre decisions that you can live with, but compound over time to slow you down. You never really learn what's going wrong, your team doesn't improve. Give me the former, painful though it may be in the moment.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by lkrubner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:43AM (#17332551)
Your answer is idealistic in a very limited way. You are suggesting that their is moral value in being humble and accepting the input of other people. I'll point out that it is even more moral to fight for what you know is right, and it is not moral to retreat from the fight simply because it is exhausting or tedious or repetitive or badly managed or the odds are lopsided. Over the last 20 years I've run into people with your attitude many times. I believe I understand your argument -- that sometimes we have to accept outcomes that we disagree with. However, what my life has taught me is that their is no valor in being passive while bad decisions are made. When I'm hired, I've been hired as an experienced professional whose advice is valuable, therefore I have an ethical obligation to fight as hard as I possibly can to be sure what I've learned over the years ends up benefiting the company. That is what I'm paid for. Passive acceptance of bad outcomes is neither ethical nor moral. We each have an obligation to fight as much as we can for what we know to be right. In the professional context, that is what we are being paid for.

As a practical matter, "be humble and accept the input of others" quickly shades over into "be lazy and allow stupid people to dominate the meeting, because letting them dominate the meeting is easier than fighting them." I agree it is easier, but it is unethical to accept money while allowing bad decisions to be made.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by turingcompeteme on Sunday June 17, 2018 @11:07AM (#17332663)
You seem to be focusing on a situation where there is a proposed solution with an obvious bad outcome, and somehow you are the only one smart enough to realize it will lead to a bad outcome.

In my experience this is very rarely the actual case. Usually there are multiple viewpoints, multiple solutions, and while some may be slightly better than others, the effort of having the debate is much more time and resource-intensive than just accepting one of the solutions.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by jstimpfle on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:13PM (#17333518)
> the effort of having the debate is much more time and resource-intensive than just accepting one of the solutions.

Man, have you ever seen bad code?

For an example, suppose someone comes up with the idea of making dozens of mini-modules with poorly defined interfaces, each one having no clue about what's going on globally, that should somehow contribute to solving a simple problem. Each interacts with each other through some sort of worm hole where you have only a vague idea what's on the other side.

Another possibility is to look at the requirements as a whole and write a single module that solves the problem in a straightforward way. Now, should one accept the first idea and write 3 or 4 times the amount of hard to code, the code being unmaintainable because the interactions between the many moving parts are very hard to understand? Just because everybody thinks that's how it should be done?

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by lkrubner on Sunday June 17, 2018 @01:32PM (#17333320)
By definition the answer you think best is the answer that all of your skills and all of your experiences guide you to. I’m saying you have an obligation to fight for what you know is the right answer. There is nothing ethical about allowing people to make decisions that you believe will be catastrophic. You are being paid for your expertise — don’t accept money if you are not willing to do what you can to ensure a good outcome.

This has nothing to do with having a debate in a meeting, indeed, often the best strategy is to avoid the meeting altogether.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by ozim on Sunday June 17, 2018 @02:02PM (#17333458)
Yes, agreed but that is what I also wrote, you should prevent catastrophic outcomes. I did not wrote anything what you implied in previous comment. I only implied that there is many technical decisions which are nowhere near to catastrophic.

Like picking tabs vs spaces, I am not going to fight about it, it is not a decision that will make any difference for product.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by euroclydon on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:56AM (#17332158)
Robert Moses would never have let any of that happen. There’s a lot of hierarchy in companies, naturally. The team constructs are artificially induced.
Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by ricardobeat on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:23AM (#17332264)
Is that the guy who inspired generations of architects and engineers to build inhumane car-centric cities, and wanted a six-lane highway crossing through Manhattan? A good example of determined management, yes, but what about the outcomes?
Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by tacostakohashi on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:28AM (#17332280)
Maybe we work in different kinds of companies. In my experience with large corporates, sure we have hierarchy in the form of an org chart, managers and job titles / levels, but management very rarely enforce outcomes or resolve day-to-day disputes.

When it comes to getting coworkers or other teams on board with a new workflow or tool, it's really completely up to powers of persuasion, providing good examples, documenting, and letting people move at their own pace. It can be frustrating to work through, but it's probably for the best, in the sense that it probably is genuinely the best tool or workflow that will win out over time, instead of the favorite of some senior person that doesn't know all the details.

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by darkerside on Sunday June 17, 2018 @10:29AM (#17332500)
If you have a high degree of confidence in your solution, then this seems like an unnecessary introduction of uncertainty, indicating a lack of leadership. Your team will start having the wrong discussion and invest their time in a fractured way, leading to frustration down the road. Why waste your team's time like this?

OTOH, if you don't trust the solution you have with a high degree of certainty, absolutely gather your team's input.

The corollary is, if you don't already know your team extremely well, how is it that your degree of certainty is high?

Re:How to Get Your Teammates to Follow Your Lead by kylequest on Sunday June 17, 2018 @12:22PM (#17333013)
Sounds like design by committee...