Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by jedberg on Saturday June 16, 2018 @06:14PM
(#17329751)
Relatedly, we're screwing up the already nocturnal animals too. Street lights get mis-perceived as sunlight, keeping them in.
We actually started fixing this by switching to sodium bulbs, which was better for humans too, but now with the push to LED, we're undoing the fix that we did, again hurting both the wildlife and ourselves in the process.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by st26 on Saturday June 16, 2018 @06:40PM
(#17329873)
Thanks for bringing this up!
It can be addressed with warmer LED's, filtered LED, narrow-band LED... trouble is the bulk of the market is at 4K & 5K white balance, so that's the default choice to put in.
The good news about LED is, due to more even color profile, they can use dramatically less lux, but that requires adjustment to lighting level too.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by jedberg on Saturday June 16, 2018 @06:59PM
(#17329945)
> they can use dramatically less lux
They can, but at least what I've seen around California is that they don't. The one outside my window is a good example. It was replaced with LED and now it's like a spotlight right into my window. I didn't even realize there was a light there when it was HPS.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by jws on Saturday June 16, 2018 @08:23PM
(#17330248)
It varies, but a call to your local jurisdiction can get a shade put on a light. My city painted a segment of the nearby intersection’s diffuser black so it doesn’t shine in my eyes when I’m on my balcony.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by always_good on Saturday June 16, 2018 @10:37PM
(#17330624)
> we're screwing up the already nocturnal animals too
Every night I look up at my exterior lights to admire the horde of geckos waiting patiently around each one for the onslaught of bugs to begin bumping into the lights.
I always wondered how different the gecko vs bug population would be without night lights. I've always felt bad for bugs.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by corbpie on Sunday June 17, 2018 @06:30AM
(#17331751)
Surely animals learn and adapt. A possum wont spend its whole life in its hollow because the light pole nearby is making it believe daytime is 24hrs 7 days a week.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by pdpi on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:15AM
(#17332224)
Sure. It can come out while there’s (artificial) light out, which probably means that it’s exposed to predators who, in between artificial light and human activity, have moved their hours of activity into the later hours. Riskier behaviour means more chances to get themselves killed.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by lurquer on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:39PM
(#17334480)
But, that's incorrect. The safest place for a small mammal to be is where humans live. Humans do not tolerate large predators in their environment. In my semi-urban neighborhood, we have huge herds of deer lounging around all the front yards. Why? Easy food. And, a neighborhood full of very clever primates who have eradicated all the Bears, wolves, badgers, etc. PLUS these clever primates have domesticated dogs that chase off coyotes but, generally, leave the deer alone.
I suspect you can find more wildlife per square mile in a rural neighborhood than you could in true wilderness.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by icelancer on Saturday June 16, 2018 @06:18PM
(#17329775)
>> We actually started fixing this by switching to sodium bulbs, which was better for humans too, but now with the push to LED, we're undoing the fix that we did, again hurting both the wildlife and ourselves in the process.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by jedberg on Saturday June 16, 2018 @06:26PM
(#17329815)
HPS uses slightly more energy than LED, but since the power comes from the grid, if you power it with "green energy" then it doesn't really matter pollution-wise, and cost-wise it takes a long time to recoup the cost of switching all the bulbs in energy savings.
The more important reason to switch is that the LEDs give a whiter light, which improves driver reaction time at night.
However, there have been no studies comparing if accidents have actually gone down in cities that switched to LED, which would in theory account for increased sleep deprivation due to more white light at night.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by shalmanese on Saturday June 16, 2018 @07:59PM
(#17330166)
> if you power it with "green energy" then it doesn't really matter pollution-wise, and cost-wise it takes a long time to recoup the cost of switching all the bulbs in energy savings.
It doesn't matter what energy source any individual application is using, it only matters what happens at the margin. For example, if a city switching to slightly more efficient lightbulbs allows a coal power plant to be mothballed one year earlier, then it saves an entire year of coal power emissions from happening.
Furthermore, streetlights operate on a complete inverse power curve to solar, meaning that additional solar is very unlikely to benefit streetlight power.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by 21 on Saturday June 16, 2018 @07:55PM
(#17330155)
But apparently they are much worse in clear weather, so the new EU regulation require white lights:
> Whilst yellow light improves visibility in wet or foggy conditions, it can also be harder to see with yellow lights in clear conditions. As a result, many vehicles today use yellow lights only as fog lights.
> White lights are the most popular colour for the headlights of today. In many countries, headlights are no longer allowed to be yellow and must be white in colour. European regulations, for example, require all new vehicles to be manufactured with white headlights.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by oldcynic on Saturday June 16, 2018 @09:10PM
(#17330387)
I can only find that claim on a Powerbulbs store blog post.
Current UN regs do indeed require white. Definitely not "much worse", more like simply different. They were very yellow, right out there with sodium lighting and obliterated colour acuity. So highly unlikely to be coming back. :)
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by Fnoord on Sunday June 17, 2018 @07:44AM
(#17331960)
This is your opinion, not a consensus-based viewpoint (feel free to link studies though).
Yellow light is more romantic and it creates melatonin. White light keeps people alert due to the blue light in it. What you prefer, depends on your interests. On the road, people need to be awake. For that purpose white light does make sense.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by 21 on Sunday June 17, 2018 @11:02AM
(#17332643)
It's not consensus, but there is no consensus either that yellow light is better. Here are some comments from the past, when yellow light was introduced:
> Another skeptic was the Tribune’s legendary architecture critic Paul Gapp. “[Sodium vapor lamps] are more than twice as bright as the blue mercury vapor lights which they would replace and produce an artificial daylight effect whose peculiar offensiveness must be visually experienced to be understood. How can it be said?” Gapp wrote in 1974. “One looks at the eerie, ominous quality of sodium vapor illumination and thinks of the bizarre paintings of Hieronymous Bosch, the frightening futurism of Stanley Kubrick’s A Clockwork Orange, and other nightmares.”
> The jaundiced weirdness of sodium light has become a vexing challenge to photographers (one filmmaker, Tenolian Bell, called it “the ugliest light known to the cinematographer”); movie cameras simulate its color by using a gel filter named Bastard Amber. Significantly, retailers have avoided inflicting the unpleasantness of sodium lights on their customers—most commercial parking lots and shopping malls use the costlier white metal halide lights.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by perpetualcrayon on Sunday June 17, 2018 @05:53AM
(#17331650)
Once technology allows us to more completely bridge the communication gap between humans and animals I think we'll realize that animals have been communicating amongst themselves in sophisticated ways for a long time and they won't have very nice things to say about us.
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by KMag on Sunday June 17, 2018 @08:51AM
(#17332142)
Perhaps you're right about cetaceans or octopi, but as far as terrestrial animals, I haven't seen any evidence that any of them are smarter than a young human child.
What makes you think terrestrial animals are smarter than young children, or that something less intelligent than a young child has any coherent commentary?
Re:Humans Are Turning Mammals More Nocturnal
by xg15 on Saturday June 16, 2018 @06:36PM
(#17329855)
Not sure if this was studied here, but I wonder if it's really "humans" or if its humans of modern-day, industrialized, "western" culture. E.g., do indigenous populations have the same effect on animals?
We actually started fixing this by switching to sodium bulbs, which was better for humans too, but now with the push to LED, we're undoing the fix that we did, again hurting both the wildlife and ourselves in the process.
It can be addressed with warmer LED's, filtered LED, narrow-band LED... trouble is the bulk of the market is at 4K & 5K white balance, so that's the default choice to put in.
The good news about LED is, due to more even color profile, they can use dramatically less lux, but that requires adjustment to lighting level too.
They can, but at least what I've seen around California is that they don't. The one outside my window is a good example. It was replaced with LED and now it's like a spotlight right into my window. I didn't even realize there was a light there when it was HPS.
Every night I look up at my exterior lights to admire the horde of geckos waiting patiently around each one for the onslaught of bugs to begin bumping into the lights.
I always wondered how different the gecko vs bug population would be without night lights. I've always felt bad for bugs.
I suspect you can find more wildlife per square mile in a rural neighborhood than you could in true wilderness.
What's the tradeoff on electricity use, though?
The more important reason to switch is that the LEDs give a whiter light, which improves driver reaction time at night.
However, there have been no studies comparing if accidents have actually gone down in cities that switched to LED, which would in theory account for increased sleep deprivation due to more white light at night.
It doesn't matter what energy source any individual application is using, it only matters what happens at the margin. For example, if a city switching to slightly more efficient lightbulbs allows a coal power plant to be mothballed one year earlier, then it saves an entire year of coal power emissions from happening.
Furthermore, streetlights operate on a complete inverse power curve to solar, meaning that additional solar is very unlikely to benefit streetlight power.
The idea being that the removal of blue light reduces the likelihood of dazzle, especially in rain and fog.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selective_yellow
> Whilst yellow light improves visibility in wet or foggy conditions, it can also be harder to see with yellow lights in clear conditions. As a result, many vehicles today use yellow lights only as fog lights.
> White lights are the most popular colour for the headlights of today. In many countries, headlights are no longer allowed to be yellow and must be white in colour. European regulations, for example, require all new vehicles to be manufactured with white headlights.
Current UN regs do indeed require white. Definitely not "much worse", more like simply different. They were very yellow, right out there with sodium lighting and obliterated colour acuity. So highly unlikely to be coming back. :)
Yellow light is more romantic and it creates melatonin. White light keeps people alert due to the blue light in it. What you prefer, depends on your interests. On the road, people need to be awake. For that purpose white light does make sense.
> Another skeptic was the Tribune’s legendary architecture critic Paul Gapp. “[Sodium vapor lamps] are more than twice as bright as the blue mercury vapor lights which they would replace and produce an artificial daylight effect whose peculiar offensiveness must be visually experienced to be understood. How can it be said?” Gapp wrote in 1974. “One looks at the eerie, ominous quality of sodium vapor illumination and thinks of the bizarre paintings of Hieronymous Bosch, the frightening futurism of Stanley Kubrick’s A Clockwork Orange, and other nightmares.”
> The jaundiced weirdness of sodium light has become a vexing challenge to photographers (one filmmaker, Tenolian Bell, called it “the ugliest light known to the cinematographer”); movie cameras simulate its color by using a gel filter named Bastard Amber. Significantly, retailers have avoided inflicting the unpleasantness of sodium lights on their customers—most commercial parking lots and shopping malls use the costlier white metal halide lights.
The LED lights are even more like daylight. This would appear to undermine the original poster who preferred LED.
Regardless, I'm not sure your opinion is universal. There was a pretty big protest against them in my city, Montreal, and the mayor relented.
What makes you think terrestrial animals are smarter than young children, or that something less intelligent than a young child has any coherent commentary?
I prefer a gentle mooing. Who cares what my burger thinks?