Re:Blooming Password – A banned password check using a bloom...
by Kalium on Friday June 15, 2018 @07:14PM
(#17324518)
You're right! That is a super cool idea. It would let you spot a user re-using passwords and warn them not to.
However, there might be some complexities. This is basically poor-password-handling as a well-intentioned service. It means anyone breaching any of the services the hub knows about would let you see a great many username/password pairings being checked. It would take make passwords as safe as the weakest link across all the services being checked. The odds of N services all being absolutely safe all at once aren't as good as those of a single service. This is why people shouldn't re-use passwords, right?
I can see your heart is in the right place. You're looking to protect users from themselves! That's a wonderful thing, and I'm so glad that there are people like you who care. But the above outcome might not be maximally desirable, you know?
However, there might be some complexities. This is basically poor-password-handling as a well-intentioned service. It means anyone breaching any of the services the hub knows about would let you see a great many username/password pairings being checked. It would take make passwords as safe as the weakest link across all the services being checked. The odds of N services all being absolutely safe all at once aren't as good as those of a single service. This is why people shouldn't re-use passwords, right?
I can see your heart is in the right place. You're looking to protect users from themselves! That's a wonderful thing, and I'm so glad that there are people like you who care. But the above outcome might not be maximally desirable, you know?