[1]Prefer working at Google to Oracle? Fair enough. Rather work at Apple than Microsoft? Ha, have fun with that.
Why would these companies choose to do that?
The particular companies involved make me think this really is about good partnership relations - until Android, Apple and Google had a really good relationship, Apple and Pixer share a head honcho, they all buy from Intel, Intuit's not really a competitor to any of them, etc. The effect, of course, is to drive down wages for the employees who would otherwise have been poached, and that's why the DoJ got involved. But I doubt that execs at each of those companies were telling themselves "We're going to drive down wages for our key employees" when they made the policy.
I also believe that collusion was made much easier by the existing good relationships you refer to.
Where we may part ways is on what the execs were saying to themselves. I don't think it was just about maintaining good relations. I believe it was about reducing the cost of having to replace key institutional knowledge. It is worth skipping out on raw talent (that will need training) if it results in keeping key people.
Which brings us back to my point. Microsoft, Oracle and Yahoo do not have good reputations among tech people. So they are not major threats to losing institutional knowledge. And they are a great source of candidates. So it isn't in the interests of Apple, Google, etc to extend the agreement to those companies.
Kind of the same problem that kept it from happening with Facebook, but with the roles reversed.
The article states that the company agreed not to use the most aggressive recruitment techniques (cold calling) on each other, which sounds like a gentlemen agreement more than collusion.
Google states that they recruited from Adobe, Intel, Apple, etc., that's pretty easy to verify.
In my simplistic (possibly wrong) view; If you look at employment as a market place, and individual employees as different commodities, it keeps the market price of employees (specifically the extremely talented ones) artificially low. In the extreme it would be similar to price fixing. This is good for Larry and Sergei and Steve, but not good for the rest of us.
They shouldn't be making any agreements about hiring practices. (Gentlemen's or not).
The article mentions that employees should know their worth, but doesn't mention how? The only way to know is to either actively seek a new job and get offers or be approached through cold calling. This ruling clearly helps the employee.
Here's much better analysis:
excerpt:
It's not just that their actions are shameful.
It's not just that these actions violate everything Silicon Valley represents.
These agreements reveal a profound insecurity about their ability to compete on free and fair terms with one another.
Maybe I'm reading too much into it, but I don't think the deal was at all about maintaining good partner relations. I think it was more about trying to hold wages down in the valley. I realize that it was only a handful of companies, but those are the companies that literally everyone else looks to (for wage levels) and competes with for employees. It's quite possible that that agreement had very real effects on average salaries.