Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists
by Gys on Friday June 15, 2018 @07:15AM
(#17318921)
The questions asked by the parlement (and the US senate) to Mark Zuckerberg show very clearly how minimal knowledge politicians have of the reality as percieved by 'the rest of us'.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists
by mathinpens on Friday June 15, 2018 @10:33AM
(#17320040)
did you actually read or watch the whole testimony (of either testimony) or you basing this on ~5 minutes of youtube click bait footage of older senators being confused...
I watched the entire zuckerberg united states senate testimony and I found much of the questioning incisive and valuable
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists
by Gys on Friday June 15, 2018 @11:15AM
(#17320301)
I admit I only read some articles on both encounters (in reputable newspapers). However, those are very much in line with my personal experiences from the years that was running a media company. Politicians are focussed on getting in office and staying there. Being friends with (listing to) the big guys (big names, important companies) is cool and good for status. Mingling with the little guys is only neccessary every so many years (because, what do they know anyway ?). Yes, it made me a little frustrated ;-)
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists
by lakechfoma on Friday June 15, 2018 @11:34AM
(#17320491)
I watched a couple of hours of it myself and saw moments like the "senator, we run ads" moment happen. A lot of the things the media was running off about was taken well out of context. That moment, for example, was not nearly as "oh my god look at this old fart" as Twitter made it. They had already established the fact that FB makes money off ads and the senator was basically poking to see if there was any thought towards another way to make money.
Honestly a fair number of quality questions were asked and deflected by Zuck, and he knew how to play some moments to make the senators look stupid for those social media soundbites. But to be fair, an alarming number of questions were also either very poorly formed (intention was there, a millennial proofread would have helped though) or were thinly veiled self indulgent political maneuvers. Zuck actually did a good job defending net neutrality at one point where the line of questioning was obviously a nod to the ISP cabal.
Re:EU copyright reforms draw fire from scientists
by dangjc on Friday June 15, 2018 @11:02PM
(#17325574)
I don’t think content providers like newspapers feel exposing snippets that are so informative that readers stop engaging with the main site are being provided a valuable service. Google has long since moved away from simply providing ten blue links and now strives to keep people as long as possible on its own site. There’s a trade off between aggregators and the content providers they rely on, and this is a minor correction needed.
In other words, this proposed rule is to address the made-up problem that publishers aren't content that third-party news aggregators are doing them a favor by sending them readers; they want to milk them for additional revenue.
The EU parliament committee seems to be acting consistent with the belief that fixing this perceived unfairness is more important than considering the unintentional negative side-effects.