It's reminds me of well-funded think-tanks providing experts with academic credentials very articulately arguing that supply-side effects are a great reason to cut taxes for the super-rich and decrease or privatize those costly public services.
How many think-tanks advocating increasing taxes for the rich to pay for public services for all get a steady income stream?
It's like a biased random walk. Sometimes things go backwards a bit, but the direction's set by underlying bias of the system.
> Variations of this idea are the root of all the bullshit
Yep. Now people like Richard Stallman are also copyright experts, too. But in general, the bias is goes the other way.
I think it's a general phenomenon most (but not all) lawyers specialising in a field favour stricter laws in that field. Imagine you are a specialist copyright lawyer. Your most obvious potential clients are big rights owners, you will try to go to the same parties as them and imbibe their world-view.
Variations of this idea are the root of all the bullshit that has began with the DMCA and keeps on with periodical attempts to expand it with SOPA/PIPA/ACTA etc.