News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Nationalism by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday June 14, 2018 @03:38PM (#17314687)
>> AI isn’t going to take over the world until it is able to, and then it very rapidly does.

The question is, of course- how? How will AI become able to take over the world?

This is an important question to ask because predictions of AI rapidly becoming capable of taking over the world tend to flare up in times of progress in AI performance. For example, the above article is basically based on the preimse that the latest developments, i.e. deep learning, are sufficient to give some nation-state technological supremacy by leading directly to AGI.

However, there is no clear path from deep learning, however powerful it may be as a set of techniques to train classifiers, to AGI, which (well, probably) entails much more than powerful classification. For instance, deep learning can't really do inference. It seems reasonable to assume that AGI will need the ability to reason about the objects it can recognise and the relations between them. Deep learning can't do causal analysis- like Judea Pearl has been screaming from the rooftops lately. It seems reasonable again to assume that AGI will need to model causal relations. Deep learning can't do semantics. AGI will need to have some handle on semantics. And so on and so forth.

In general, anyone that claims that X current development in AI risks inadvertently producing AGI, must explain how this is supposed to happen- not just wave their hands about and claim that, if you throw enough compute and enough data at the problem, magic will happen and AGI will turn us all into paperclips.

There are no comments on this comment yet.