But yes, with all these benefits, I'm really amazed when I hear people talk as if the whole tax system is basically fraud (as opposed to taxes just being too high). Unless they're very idealistic libertarians, of course. Or live in New Jersey.
Yups, the Netherlands is luckily still one of those. :)
I think the benefit of "fairness" that results from having everyone go though the same schools and hospitals is far greater then any of the benefits you mention.
Proof that this occurs: http://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2006/08/20/100/
Another far more dangerous effect is that the rich might produce less. If they produce goods abroad, the only deadweight loss is the cost of shipping. For every good/service not produced, we lose the entire consumer surplus. One famous (albeit historical) example of this is that actor Ronald Reagan only made one movie a year - due to high taxes, making two movies/year earned him virtually no additional income.
The only remaining question is the degree to which these effects occur.
The only real point he makes is that taxing the rich too much will drive them abroad. As far as i know there is no proof for this.
I feel another problem is more important than scaring out the rich by higher taxation: when tax money is largely used for public services like schools and health care that the rich dont use as they prefer the better private alternatives. In Kamerschen's words this will give the rich the feeling they pay more for the beer, that they dont even drink!
Coming from the netherlands, i value that public schools and hospitals are being used regardless of pay grade. This justifies paying tax for everyone, and gives a sense of fair chances in society regardless your social-economic background.