There are times for the federal government to run a deficit and inject money into the economy, but when it's done largely as a corporate tax cut in a time of full employment and record corporate profits (both indicating that businesses don't see many opportunities to reinvest in themselves), you'd expect to see that money go out as stock buybacks and dividends. And that's exactly what we've been seeing. There's no need to wait for long term lag effects if the short term investments that are the only plausible story for those effects materializing simply haven't happened.
Yes, the stock market has been propped up, but it's with fool's gold; there are no gains in either productivity or national capital stocks (public or private). Meanwhile, increase in debt service as a percentage of the federal budget has been guaranteed. The burden of proof is on the tax cut authors to prove the short term growth that justifies it.
If your point is "well, the economy is a very complicated system", that's an argument for avoiding a large drastic action done to that system against the vast majority of expert economic advice, not for it. This tax cut wasn't even the typical "We need to do something. This is something!" fallacy, it was "We don't need to do anything. This is something!".
If you have to pay more on your mortgage and credit cards then that's less you can put into the stock market and invest in other things.
If the tax cuts didn't vastly improve performance then they hurt a lot. They increased an already large deficit even more for which future generations will have to the pay the price.
The timescale for the determination is not left up to months. I don't personally think they were good, but to assert that you can tell right away, is disingenuous. The debt is already so large that this barely affects the momentum.
The idea that a 66% increase in the deficit "barely affects the momentum" is absurd reflects either your ignorance or your bad faith. Apply that logic to your personal spending and see how long it takes before you're bankrupt.
You’re free to disagree, but it will help the discussion if you can find a way to do so without the ad hominems.
Again, I’m not arguing that it’s a good idea. It is irresponsible, for sure. But the scale of it is akin to somebody with $10k in credit card debt opting to go out for dinner once.
Yes, there is. People seem to forget that a tax cut is actually a government subsidy. Coupled with increased spending, if the assumption is that if the macroeconomic performance hasn't been improved that means it hasn't been hurt, then it remained constant despite the 'cuts' + 'increased spending'. Which means that it could have grown/improved if the tax cuts were not in place.
Do you also believe that reducing drag on a moving object is actually increasing the force to move it?
A government subsidy is when public money is SPENT on a good or service to artificially encourage investment in it (or someone just has good lobbyists).
An income tax cut is reducing the burden businesses and individuals must incur from producing economic value.
While taxes and subsidies can both be used by government to encourage selective behavior, they are not the same. They are different instruments and operate differently.
You're making the assumption that everything has an immediate effect. Some things incur a cost in the present for a payout in the future.
If you go to college for 6 months (the amount of time the tax bill has been in place) and still don't have a degree or job, does that imply that going to college doesn't work?
You're also making the assumption that this is a controlled experiment with no other variables. Which is not the case. There are many other things in play.
Let me guess, cutting welfare payments is stealing?
And yes, cutting welfare payments while welfare payouts are constant/growing will be taking money from other sources to keep the balance. So depending on one's definition of stealing, it can be.
All of this seems like gross oversimplification and it worries me that it is so common.
Words have definitions and meanings and when you conflate them you reduce your ability to understand and reason about the world.
I see why people think not doing something is equivalent of its opposite but this is not the case.
Not taxing someone is not the same things as subsidizing them for the same reason that not expressing hate is not the same thing as expressing love. Not attacking someone is not the same as healing them. Hospitals can't heal people by simply not attacking them.
Police reduce violent crime but it would be inaccurate to say that police are the same as hospitals because they both reduce personal injury.
Not doing harmful drugs and studying both make you smarter, but not doing drugs is not the same as studying.
That’s not how it works.
That's literally one form of subsidy. Also, did you know that inflation is a form of taxation? And it is indeed rising. So no, it's not actually letting people keep more of the money, especially if it's cash.
When a word gets used incorrectly or conflated enough even official dictionaries will change.
What's important is to understand the distinctions.
There's something called Sapir-Whorf theory and one of the important concepts is that the more precision your definitions the more capable you are at cognition and understanding and interacting with the world.
It's been said that Eskimos have 37 words for snow. This means that each different type of snow has different properties. They can more effectively operate in that environment compared to someone who thinks all snow is the same.
Some would say that ice and water are the same, and in many ways they are correct, they are the exact same molecules, but if you are going to jump 3 stories off of a diving board onto solid ice instead of water you are going to learn that subtle distinction real fast.
Similarly, conflating taxes and subsidizes reduces your ability to understand the distinctions and their different consequences. And when it comes to implementing policies can have similar effects as mistaking ice for water.
It's important to understand things precisely and not conflate things. Even more so when your votes and actions have a consequence on other people's lives as well.
We understand why you think they are the same, and in many contexts they can safely be conflated, but in many others it is dangerous to assume they are the same.
Which would imply that any gains (or losses) now would have to do with policy changes during the prior administration, supporting the author's point.
So, alright, what's misleading the implication that they could have any significant effect by now.
https://www.numbersusa.com/news/more-400000-asylum-seekers-o...
Wages would be going way up if Trump were actually delivering in terms of deportations and the cessation of guest worker programs.
This is probably true. But there's also no evidence to support that it hurt either. It's quite disingenuous and misleading to make such claims when there hasn't even been a single year of tax filings since the new tax policies have taken effect. Policies, especially tax policies, have long lag effects.
Also, there are so many variables and other factors to consider that it is impossible to think so 1-dimensionally.