Re:Intel SA-00145: Lazy FP State Restore
by jcranmer on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @09:20PM
(#17308489)
I should clarify that the idea that is wrong is that just exposing the hardware bits to the compiler and expecting the compiler to do better. There is certainly more scope for the compiler and the hardware to work together to make the results better, but exposing current hardware mechanisms is not the means to do to that. Of course, try getting architecture and compiler people actually talking to each other. :-)
I worked on compilers too, and I think there is definitely still work to be explored here. Really, complicated OoO speculative processors are simply recovering a lot of the information the compiler already calculated! You take this code that is in no way suited for a CPU, and you do a ton of dataflow and high-level analysis on it (that you can only know from the source). You build this graph and optimized based on these facts. And then, you throw away the dataflow graph when you lower things. All this, after painfully calculating it on the assumed basis of "Yes, the CPU will like this code" -- only for the CPU to perform that whole process over again, say "Yes, I do, in fact, like this code" -- so it can execute efficiently without stalls anyway. There's clearly a mismatch here.
I mean, don't get me wrong -- this all seems like a perfectly fine and acceptable engineering tradeoff, but just disappointing from a computer science perspective, to me, at least, that this is not unified :) Of course, VLIW vs CISC etc is one of the classic debates...
Interestingly, Aaron Smith from Microsoft Research (and one of the original members of the TRIPS project) actually demonstrated and talked about their work on newer EDGE processor designs at MSR, and even demonstrated Windows running on an EDGE processor, this past week or so at ISCA2018 (complete with a working Visual Studio target, using an LLVM-based toolchain!) Their design is quite different from TRIPS it seems. I'm hoping the talks/work becomes public eventually, but that might just be a dream.