News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This car is on Autopilot. What happens next? by ovao on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @02:49PM (#17305938)
The driver in front also knew about the stationary ‘car’ well ahead of time and was instructed to avoid it by merging into another lane. An actual human driver in a real scenario may perform better than the Tesla, as well as the Tesla or worse than the Tesla — it just depends.
Re:This car is on Autopilot. What happens next? by nmeofthestate on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @11:21AM (#17347478)
Tesla's algorithm is "try to slow down, but nevertheless plow into stuff if that doesn't work". It is demonstrably worse than the human algorithm of "slow down, but also steer to avoid obstacles". I can't see how you can objectively say they're equally good.
Re:This car is on Autopilot. What happens next? by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @11:25AM (#17347529)
Do we want a car deciding whether to leave the lane? Leave the road? It could do more harm than good. We'll have to decide this, soon. By law hopefully - some standards for auto-drive and what it's allowed to do.

Because if we don't, software will have to code up the 'trolly car problem' solution, starting now. Hit the school bus ahead? or the guy walking beside the road? or the brick wall (and kill its passenger)? There's no good (universally defendable) solution.

Re:This car is on Autopilot. What happens next? by GreaterFool on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:29PM (#17307129)
I'd argue that the car in front is at fault changing lanes at last possible second. This may or may not leave the drivers behind enough time to follow suit. Clearly this is a manufactured situation but in order to draw conclusions I'd like to see tests when unsuspecting human driers follows the leading car.

I re-watched the video and it really doesn't look like the Tesla is breaking. The video says "unable to break in time". This to me sounds misleading. It is not clear whether Tesla tried to break but the distance was too short or it didn't attempt to break. Which leads me to conclude there's an agenda here.

Re:This car is on Autopilot. What happens next? by ovao on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:37PM (#17307190)
It can't be deduced from the footage alone whether the Model S is braking or not, but it's clear that it decelerates and stops after it impacts the dummy car.

In the U.S. at least, it's highly unlikely that the driver in front would be found legally at fault in a similar accident. In most cases of rear-end collisions, the driver who impacts the rear of the car will be found at fault.