News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel to Release Discrete Graphics Card in 2020 by crb002 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:12PM (#17299728)
I'm surprised they don't make lossy GPUs that have a few defects among the obscene amount of transistors. Consumer graphics you wouldn't know the difference.
Re:Intel to Release Discrete Graphics Card in 2020 by exikyut on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @07:27AM (#17302072)
Interesting idea.

I assume you mean that each GPU gets a variable number of execution units, as opposed to code randomly failing depending on the core it gets run on.

You've just helped me realize that AMD and Nvidia overproduce every GPU and kill off the execution cores that don't work to reach the final fixed number (and that all GPUs probably have a few tens to hundreds of working cores that will never ever be used).

Unfortunately I don't think such variation would work, from a market standpoint: actually exposing the lossiness rating would devalue you as a manufacturer, solely because of the fact that the media would pounce on it like crazy, and even though said media would simply report what's there without putting malice in anyone's mouth, the fuss would mean naive users would go "wat", collectively conclude "well the number is smaller", interpret that to mean "vague less-iness", and bam, people don't think your product is as good.

Despite the fact that, for all intents and purposes (read: not mining), you are 100% right.

Re:Intel to Release Discrete Graphics Card in 2020 by theandrewbailey on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @01:55PM (#17305477)
> You've just helped me realize that AMD and Nvidia overproduce every GPU and kill off the execution cores that don't work to reach the final fixed number (and that all GPUs probably have a few tens to hundreds of working cores that will never ever be used).

That's basically the idea, but it's usually scaled down. A single GPU generation is essentially one chip design. If a single die has a defect in a particular unit, its turned/soldered off at the factory and sold as a lower end chip. Repeat until you have a chip that works. If you have a die where everything works, clock it up as much as you can, and ask a king's ransom for it.

The best exception is the PS3 "Cell" CPU.[0] It had an extra 'sacrificial' processing core.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cell_(microprocessor)#Commerci...

Re:Intel to Release Discrete Graphics Card in 2020 by david-gpu on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @09:32AM (#17302850)
Lossy compression is widely used for textures. Low-precision data formats are also very commonly used for other data. Etc.
Re:Intel to Release Discrete Graphics Card in 2020 by theandrewbailey on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @01:45PM (#17305380)
No one does, for the same reason that no one makes a 'lossy' CPU.