Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by Animats on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:03PM
(#17295291)
You don't need a "blockchain" for timestamps. There have been timestamping services for years.[1] There's a standard: RFC 3161. Many of the SSL cert providers also have a timestamping service.
Timestamping would be very useful if Google used signed timestamps to determine provenance. Scraper sites should be outranked by the original source.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by 456hdsaq234g on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:51PM
(#17295875)
You need a blockchain for decentralised timestamps. That is because a blockchain is basically a slow clock. Its not easy to spoof as you would need to spoof the Proof of Work. Any existing signature relies on a 3rd party trusted clock (like symantecs signing service for Authenticode).
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by tylersmith on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:01PM
(#17296732)
In the white paper it's literally called the "timestamp server" and that is its sole function. Timestamping transactions in a decentralized environment.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by __jal on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:44PM
(#17296529)
You could have stopped at
> You don't need a "blockchain"
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by matthewwiese on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:21PM
(#17297606)
Sure, but then I wouldn't have learned something!
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:51PM
(#17295883)
The obvious rebuttal to your claim is that those services are all centralized.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by Animats on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:46PM
(#17296567)
You can use timestamps from multiple services on the same data. There are many RFC 3161 timestamp services run by different organizations in different countries.
Wordpress could use time-stamping services to prove provenance on postings. That would be useful if Google paid attention to the timestamps.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by optimuspaul on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:32PM
(#17297704)
The obvious rebuttal is, do they need to be decentralized?
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @09:58AM
(#17303068)
To prevent any one party from being able to deceive others about the timestamp.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by briatx on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:17PM
(#17296205)
His claim was:
> You don't need a "blockchain" for timestamps.
He didn't say anything about whether the timestamp services were centralized or not.
So saying "ha, but they're centralized!" is not a rebuttal.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:21PM
(#17296269)
But that's a disingenious argument. The main reason people claim that the blockchain is a good use for timestamps is that nobody can be bribed, or hacked, to change the results.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by yifanl on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:47PM
(#17296572)
Given that the blockchain does not solve for human error, the argument for true immutability is not necessary a strict positive.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:59PM
(#17297932)
Well hey, I have and will go on record saying that the Blockchain isn't a panacea for everything - but if you do want to claim that you did X at time Y, a big blockchain is a pretty good way to register that claim.
(Note that I didn't say prove that you ddi thing X at time Y...)
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by admax88q on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:18PM
(#17298107)
Except in the case of the etherium fork.
Re:How I became Leonardo da Vinci on the Blockchain
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @09:54AM
(#17303040)
True, but that's less of a concern for timestamps, right? You can always point to the original pre-fork chain.
And because it is smart and nor an overhyped ICO, it is offered for free and actually works.
See https://opentimestamps.org/
edit: oh, it seems the project in question (veritart) is actually using opentimestamps.