Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void
by dragonwriter on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:50PM
(#17289611)
> The difference is that business partners are completely free to set the terms of their partnership.
They are not completely free; the law has bounds.
> Whereas in marriage, the terms are fixed by the state.
That's not true, there are default terms set by the state and, within the bounds of the law, they can modify them. Hence pre-(and post-)nuptial agreements.
> No business partners would enter a deal with equal shares if one brings 1M in assets and the other zero
You can probably find examples showing that that generalization is overstated, but, sure, that would be unusual.
> A marriage forces them to.
No, even in a “community property” state, it doesn't, even in the absence of a special agreement between the parties. Community property is generally that property acquired during the marriage; assets brought in at the formation remain separate property, in general.
They are not completely free; the law has bounds.
> Whereas in marriage, the terms are fixed by the state.
That's not true, there are default terms set by the state and, within the bounds of the law, they can modify them. Hence pre-(and post-)nuptial agreements.
> No business partners would enter a deal with equal shares if one brings 1M in assets and the other zero
You can probably find examples showing that that generalization is overstated, but, sure, that would be unusual.
> A marriage forces them to.
No, even in a “community property” state, it doesn't, even in the absence of a special agreement between the parties. Community property is generally that property acquired during the marriage; assets brought in at the formation remain separate property, in general.