As for equity amounts - if I have to assume your startup will grow at least 10X, without any further dilution, in order to break even on comp with a public corp, it's not a very compelling offer.
If not, then what you're really doing is offering something you hope doesn't cost you anything and is therefore worth nothing. Good luck to you.
If so, then do everything you can to help them do it. Holding an employee hostage because in order to leave they have to write a check for a significant part of their life savings won't be productive. They're taking up a salary from someone who will actually be engaged and motivated.
In my experience, this definitely plays into individuals' job offer decisionmaking. At least the most sophisticated ones, which are usually the ones you're most interested in recruiting.
is this the case? i actually don't know that it is.
Jawbone $2.7 billion valuation -> 0
Beepi $560 million -> 0
Better Place $2.5 billion -> 0
Quixey $600 million -> 0
YikYak $400 million -> $3 million
Fab.com $1.5 billion -> $15 million
Rdio $500 million -> $75 million
Here's 133 of them, most pretty big: https://www.cbinsights.com/research/biggest-startup-failures...
Also got some details from: http://www.businessinsider.com/startups-that-raised-148-bill...
I worked at a unicorn startup five years ago in the bay which no longer exists. Anyone who bought the options -- and the company was very cagey on providing cap table info -- was left with nothing.
Even if the company is sold at a high value chances are the payout will not be worth the risk. Unless your shares come with a board seat never buy the options in a private company because the shares are worth literally zero unless a secondary market exists.
:)
The equity side is pretty rough. Founders are very sensitive about disclosing important information about company performance. They are sensitive about disclosing the cap table. Some will share info with investors that they don't share with employees. And they are sometimes trying to pitch optimistically and leaving out items that don't fit the narrative. So you end up with a very vague sense of where the company actually is when you are interviewing. A much better stance is "awesome opportunity, and these are our problems, come help us fix them". Standardization on more disclosure would push hiring toward a higher local maximum.
Something like Geoff's https://blog.ycombinator.com/transparency-in-startup-investi... for hiring companies. For workatastartup.com, you could say "if we make an offer, we'll show you this critical info". It's probably a bit much to expect companies to disclose this in public job postings.
Sam's thoughts on equity at https://blog.samaltman.com/employee-equity are spot on. Especially the 10 year exercise period.
Scenario one. You leave a company after 5 years. You think they will be successful but best case is 5 years before liquidity and 10 years is very possible. It will take most of your savings to buy the stock and pay taxes. You helped with the $20 million to $800 million valuation growth. Now you have no savings, and the money is still at risk because $800 million dollar startups die all the time. You get to bet all your savings that a die rolls 1-2 for 10 times your savings. Roll 3-6 and you lose it all. The expected value is great, but it's a pretty hard bet to take.
Scenario two. Your coworkers realize this and hang on at the company long after they want to move on. Now 20% of your team is just showing up and the company culture is dying. Everyone worries about retention, we should worry about over retention too. It's better for the golden handcuffs be "if I stay, I'll vest these options" rather than "I must stay to preserve the options I vested 4 years ago".
These and 10 other bad scenarios like them are definitely on the con side.
And so easily fixed!