News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by whiddershins on Sunday June 10, 2018 @07:49PM (#17280777)
Of all the hacker news comments I’ve ever read, yours made me feel the worst.

One of the greatest living artists talking about the subjectivity of perception and you refer to it as quackery.

It hurts my heart.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by andrepd on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:19PM (#17280879)
You would be right if he was talking about the "subjectivity of perception". But he is not. He is talking about "stars exploding far away", and the expansion of the universe, and relativity. His quote, I repeat: "But what if time is actually speeding up? If everything is changing at the same speed, there is no way to measure it. [...] What I suggest is that these are not subjective, but rather objective experiences.". And this is quackery.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by keiferski on Monday June 11, 2018 @01:03AM (#17281955)
They’re having a theoretical discussion. That’s what creative people do. Turn off your scientism goggles for a second.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by retsibsi on Monday June 11, 2018 @02:18AM (#17282208)
I thought 'scientism' described excessive faith in the scientific method, and/or dogmatic positivism. How does that apply to calling someone out for explicitly invoking scientific findings in a misleading or nonsensical way?
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by keiferski on Monday June 11, 2018 @04:16AM (#17282665)
Because they’re just having a discussion about interesting ideas...? It’s not a science journal.

I used the term ‘scientism’ because the parent commenter is approaching the subject of science from a dogmatic, oppressive perspective. The entire oeuvre of someone like Jorge Luis Borges is predicated on a creative exploration and interpretation of science.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by retsibsi on Monday June 11, 2018 @04:33AM (#17282721)
I think most people have no problem with science being used as a launching pad for speculation, or a source of metaphor and artistic inspiration, or a cultural product to playfully riff on. The reason some are frustrated by the quoted lines, I think, is that Glass seems to be cloaking his poetic or metaphysical speculations in real science, and perhaps even literally putting them forward as scientific ideas. From that perspective they have more in common with the fuzzy, lazy thinking of pseudoscientists than with the fantastical literature of Borges.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by lowtolerance on Monday June 11, 2018 @08:56AM (#17283788)
If you're frustrated by a layman having a layman's understanding of theoretical physics, then you need to re-evaluate your life. Glass is a composer. No one in the world looks to him for guidance on understanding relativity.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by andrepd on Monday June 11, 2018 @10:57AM (#17284764)
No one in the world should look to Jenny McCarthy for guidance on vaccination, yet here we are. Dead kids and all.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by lowtolerance on Saturday June 16, 2018 @05:02PM (#17329407)
I’m sorry that you don’t see the difference between the two. Philip Glass isn’t an activist campaigning to alter the public’s understanding of physics. He’s just a guy relaying his beliefs in an interview where he is being pressed to explain them.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by coldtea on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:13AM (#17283314)
>I thought 'scientism' described excessive faith in the scientific method, and/or dogmatic positivism. How does that apply to calling someone out for explicitly invoking scientific findings in a misleading or nonsensical way?

Scientism would also fit to describe trying to apply scientific criteria and norms where it's not required (or desirable). Like an impromptu creative conversation about what ifs...

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by andrepd on Monday June 11, 2018 @11:57PM (#17290603)
They're not having a "theoretical discussion" any more than me reading a phone book. What they're saying is entirely meaningless, baseless, and devoid of insight.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by coldtea on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:11AM (#17283303)
>You would be right if he was talking about the "subjectivity of perception". But he is not. He is talking about "stars exploding far away", and the expansion of the universe, and relativity.

It's called having an imagination and asking hypotheticals.

He didn't put out a paper on a physics journal saying that it is so.

In fact many scientists started exactly that way -- from asking wild hypothetical questions. Whether you pursue a specific validated answer is up to your job, Glass is not a physicist.

I guess people who never had a conversation over a shared bong can never understand this.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by cgriswald on Monday June 11, 2018 @10:36AM (#17284556)
I actually vaguely recall an SR paper put forth by a relatively famous physicist that actually took the view that time was 'longer' in the past, to the point of being infinite at the big bang. This would mean the universe had always existed. IIRC, the model was mathematically valid and actually explained some observations well. Unfortunately, it did not match other observations.

While I think the OP is being, perhaps, unfair to Glass, I think everyone is being unfair to the OP as well. There are people who believe the perception of time speeding up is objective, for the reasons Glass mentions. I'm not convinced these are Glass's original ideas. And while Glass may not be a physicist, nor is Jenny McCarthy a medical researcher. And yet people still listened to what she had to say to great harm. So I can certainly understand why someone, especially someone recently exposed to people who really believe this idea, might be concerned with someone famous espousing those ideas in the way Glass has done, even if I can't see any harm myself.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by andrepd on Monday June 11, 2018 @10:55AM (#17284736)
I guess anybody is entitled to say anything they please, yet when you claim time may be speeding up based on the fact that you and your children disagree on whether the summer went by faster or slower, or when Deepak Chopra speaks about "quantum medicine", or whetever, you are being a quack.

>I guess people who never had a conversation over a shared bong can never understand this.

Sure thing, duuuude. Now we're holding a published interview to the high (no pun intended) standard of "college stoners". Great.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by coldtea on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:06AM (#17293344)
>Sure thing, duuuude. Now we're holding a published interview to the high (no pun intended) standard of "college stoners". Great.

Well,

1) Most published interviews are below the standard of "college stoners" (e.g. celebrity BS) -- so it would be a higher bar if we did so.

2) "College stoner" conversations are not that low in themselves. In fact many observations and discoveries by non-stoned people start with similar what ifs and digressions...

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by Kalium on Sunday June 10, 2018 @09:31PM (#17281120)
You're right. This is one of our greatest living artists, a human cultural treasure. We should weigh every word, every performance carefully. His work offers us incredible insight into ourselves.

Yet, is it perhaps possible that we should consider carefully how far the credibility he so justly deserves should extend. Someone with minimal qualifications talks of how his subjective experience should be considered objective, and some opine that this should be taken seriously on the basis of unrelated merit.

It hurts my head.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by moogly on Monday June 11, 2018 @02:14AM (#17282196)
Some of us don't even agree with the "one of the greatest living artists" part. Wholly subjective opinion.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by coldtea on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:15AM (#17283321)
I don't consider culture "wholly subjective". Just somewhat subjective.

There are philistines and people who only care about Justin Bieber, and their aesthetic opinions are not equally valid to someone who is an expert on Bach.

Of course that (culture) is a human construct, but so is physics and math. Animals don't have either, and the universe doesn't care either way.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by kevinwang on Sunday June 10, 2018 @07:57PM (#17280805)
Yeah, but he was making some pseudoscientific conjecture about the objectivity of time and using "expansion of the universe" to justify it, not merely the subjectivity of time passage. I mean, it's an interesting hot take, but it's definitely reminiscent of pseudoscience quackery.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by emmanuel_1234 on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:04PM (#17280830)
He literally says:

"What I suggest is that these are not subjective, but rather objective experiences. It’s also a little terrifying. What if 1,000 years from now, a life span felt like it was only a few days?"

He's talking about the objectivity of perception.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by nothrabannosir on Monday June 11, 2018 @05:11AM (#17282868)
If Stephen Hawking had ever talked about the objectivity of music or any art in such patently wrong terms, I hope people would call him out on it. Otherwise people like me might take his word for it, precisely because of his purported greatness.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by modzu on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:40PM (#17280943)
their perspective is fair for a physics undergraduate. but hopefully it changes.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by andrepd on Monday June 11, 2018 @11:59PM (#17290611)
I am no longer a physics undergraduate, by the way, I solid get that changed. But I appreciate the effort to stick to the discussion and not dig irrelevant information /s.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by braythwayt on Sunday June 10, 2018 @07:59PM (#17280811)
Also, his so-called "music." It's just basic arithmetic. Scales, for example, can be reduced to a simple 12-bit number:

https://ianring.com/musictheory/scales/

All this fluff about a "major" scale and its "modes" when we could just say "2741" and derive other relationships from rotating bits and a few other simple relationships.

Everything else, like the "subjective feeling of a Persian Scale" is just quackery. It's just someone who doesn't understand numbers making up nonsense words.

Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by ggg9990 on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:08PM (#17280851)
Hehe... nothing more HN than putting “music” in square quotes to summarily dismiss it. Please link ur Soundcloud
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by braythwayt on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:11PM (#17280860)
You got me! I am not a musician, I'm a bassist.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by lainga on Sunday June 10, 2018 @09:08PM (#17281045)
actually nothing more HN than expressing doubt or disagreement by demanding credentials out of someone
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by fenomas on Sunday June 10, 2018 @10:31PM (#17281324)
This is equivalent to saying "visual art is just basic arithmetic" because you found out that the relationships between colors can be described with bit operations on their RGB values.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by braythwayt on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:07AM (#17283288)
Leaving out the sarcasm tags is also equivalent to expecting that your code is so obvious that it doesn't need any comments.
Re:What Time Looks Like to Philip Glass by andrepd on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:16PM (#17280875)
You forgot the sarcasm tag.