News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radical Swiss financial reform campaign faces defeat by repolfx on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:04AM (#17277716)
So what? You're making the classic erroneous assumption of believing more economic activity is inherently good.

A society that spends all its time and effort on bad investments like building statues and blowing them up again, is a society with a problem, yet by the metrics used by conventional economics, it'd be doing great! Full employment! Tons of production! GDP increasing!

Re:Radical Swiss financial reform campaign faces defeat by nickik on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:56AM (#17277890)
Nobody in Switzerland is investing in useless stuff and blowing it up, so its not relevant.

As long as economic activity is driven by individuals it is inherently better.

Re:Radical Swiss financial reform campaign faces defeat by repolfx on Sunday June 10, 2018 @09:10AM (#17277942)
How do you know?

My build-statues-and-blow-it-up example was deliberately exaggerated for clarity and effect. In the real world malinvestment tends to look like asset bubbles, the construction of houses that nobody needs, "airports to nowhere" (like the cases of that happening in Spain) and so on. It may look like beneficial economic activity when you're zoomed all the way in, but when the free money dries up, suddenly it becomes clear that maybe strippers shouldn't be allocated two houses, or maybe airports should be built near population centers, and so on.

Anyone who can print money from nothing can essentially override the judgement of wider society about how best to allocate resources. Note that resources can also be allocated towards savings, but that tends to suppress economic activity, so people whose job performance is judged by measuring economic activity invariably end up attacking savings. Hence the frequency with which central banks try to push down interest rates.

Re:Radical Swiss financial reform campaign faces defeat by olliej on Sunday June 10, 2018 @05:53PM (#17280373)
I got that it was an exaggerated example, but sadly I’m 90% sure that you could make a kickstarter project to do just that and probably get it funded.

Of course at that point people are actually treating the entertainment value as an asset rather than the statue and explosives themselves so maybe that’s also completely reasonable.

Re:Radical Swiss financial reform campaign faces defeat by growlist on Sunday June 10, 2018 @01:25PM (#17279094)
This sounds like the Broken Window Fallacy to me
Re:Radical Swiss financial reform campaign faces defeat by mseebach on Sunday June 10, 2018 @03:14PM (#17279706)
GDP might be a flawed measurement for the reasons you mention, but it's worth keeping in mind that for all it's flaws it has a very high correlation with "general goodness", almost regardless of which measure you choose.