News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by toasterlovin on Saturday June 09, 2018 @12:08AM (#17271484)
I’m not so sure that a willingness to make your existence subordinate to a higher power is all that separable from doing good.
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by dragonwriter on Saturday June 09, 2018 @02:39AM (#17271851)
> I’m not so sure that a willingness to make your existence subordinate to a higher power is all that separable from doing good.

It's quite separable from doing good, as there are endless historical examples of people subordinating their existence to a higher power and doing virtually unmitigated evil as a direct consequence.

OTOH, it may be the case that recognizing a very specific kind of higher purpose than one self is deeply linked to doing good, but to the extent that is true I don't think is all that strongly correlated with religion; I do think the right framing of religion is beneficial (and wrong framings harmful) to channeling that pre-existing inclination into good results, but that's a different issue.

Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by daveFNbuck on Saturday June 09, 2018 @01:33AM (#17271697)
You seem to be saying that atheists can't do good. If you want secular folk to be more appreciative of your religion, you should be a lot more careful about expressing such bigoted sentiments about us.
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by toasterlovin on Saturday June 09, 2018 @02:32AM (#17271832)
I’m not religious, fwiw. What I said applies to both religious and non-religious people. I just think people who subordinate themselves to a higher power (or purpose) tend to be more concentrated among the religious.
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by daveFNbuck on Saturday June 09, 2018 @02:49AM (#17271872)
> What I said applies to both religious and non-religious people.

My problem is that it applies to theists in a positive way and atheists in a negative way. You complain that hardcore atheists are too critical of the worst of religion, then you say something absurdly critical about atheists.

Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by toasterlovin on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:37AM (#17271982)
I was mainly saying something about my intuition of how certain traits correlate with each other. I’m probably wrong, btw; I use HN as a thinking apparatus, so I tend to go out on a limb here and see what people push back with.
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by DoreenMichele on Saturday June 09, 2018 @02:40AM (#17271854)
I didn't read it that way at all. My ex was not religious, but was a patriot and had a military career.

There are lots of ways to devote oneself to some larger cause or purpose.

Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by daveFNbuck on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:01AM (#17271910)
My existence is not subordinate to a higher power. I read that as saying that I can't do good.
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by toasterlovin on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:47AM (#17272006)
FWIW, I should have said higher purpose. From what I have observed, most good people subordinate themselves to a higher purpose. That can be all kinds of things. Belief in doing the right thing, God, your children, etc.
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by daveFNbuck on Saturday June 09, 2018 @10:02AM (#17273056)
Tying a higher purpose to doing good is meaningless if you're just saying that good people believe in doing the right thing. I believe in doing the right thing, but I wouldn't say my existence is subordinate to that. It also doesn't make sense as a reply to someone saying that "you can walk the straight and narrow path without the carrot of eternal salvation or the stick of eternal damnation."
Re:Mr. Rogers Had a Simple Set of Rules for Talking to Children by dragonwriter on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:50AM (#17272010)
> From what I have observed, most good people subordinate themselves to a higher purpose.

So do many of the most evil people. Often, superficially at least, the same higher purpose as good people.

God, certainly, ranks high on that list.