News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maybe the Gig Economy Isn’t Reshaping Work After All by briandear on Friday June 08, 2018 @04:51PM (#17269581)
Are individuals incapable of making decisions on their own? Why shouldn’t the individual have the choice to drive or not drive as well as making decisions about their economic situation?

Nobody is forced to drive. Nobody is forced to work for less than they value their labor. Unionizing Uber means dramatically high prices, which means less demand. There isn’t a magic pot of money just waiting to be distributed. If comes from consumer pockets. If Uber gets more expensive, I’ll drive myself. So that guy that would have made $10, now makes zero because he thinks he deserves $20. So he is actually worse off now. Markets don’t work in a vacuum — there are substitutes and you can’t “fix” a problem without unintended consequences.

Let supply and demand work. Those that think they should earn more can quit and to sell their services to someone willing to pay their desired rates. If nobody will pay that desired rate, then it’s clear that the market doesn’t value that service that much.

Why is supply and demand so hard for people to understand? We oppose industrial monopolies, why would we advocate for labor monopolies via unions?

Re:Maybe the Gig Economy Isn’t Reshaping Work After All by ljm on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:19PM (#17270200)
I don't think your examples paint the picture you intended here, instead it comes across as entitled and lacking in empathy.

> "...he thinks he deserves $20."

Who said anything about deserving? You said as much that you'd drive yourself when it came to a $20 ride; you wouldn't drive yourself if it was $10. This more or less suggests the only reason Uber provides value to you is because it charges less than what you'd charge if you were providing it, because you think you deserve $20. In that instance it's not unfair to say that you get value out of Uber undercutting the competition.

> "Those that think they should earn more can quit..."

I suppose they just need to pull themselves up by their bootstraps too? Not many of us can enjoy the privilege of quitting our jobs because we know we're worth more than we're getting. I have that privilege and I use it often, like many of us do in tech. For as long as we value low prices at all costs, there will always be someone who is forced into taking on this kind of job because they don't have the luxury of choice that we do. They can't quit because it's either the $10 you want to give them, so you can save $10 for yourself, or nothing.

It's been clear enough for a long time that those who enjoy the services from others won't really advocate for them, and neither will their employers, so unions and regulations are there to sort that out.

Re:Maybe the Gig Economy Isn’t Reshaping Work After All by Thlom on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:07PM (#17269687)
Who said anything about monopolies? I though a union was just workers banding together and using their strength in number to negotiate better working conditions, better pay and so on?

It's easy for someone with a sought after talent to say normal workers can just "quit and sell their services to someone willing to pay more", but that isn't an actual option for many many people.

Re:Maybe the Gig Economy Isn’t Reshaping Work After All by trophycase on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:12PM (#17269726)
Unions solve the coordination problem and nullify the leverage a corporation has over workers. This leverage imbalance creates imperfect markets, it doesn't facilitate it. People need to eat, they need to take time to find a new job, they need to build skills. High prices of medicine is a great example: They can get away with charging so much simply because there is an imbalance between how much you need them versus how much they need you.
Re:Maybe the Gig Economy Isn’t Reshaping Work After All by _cs2017_ on Saturday June 09, 2018 @12:03PM (#17273620)
Could you elaborate? Why does employer have leverage? Other employers compete for labor and are willing to increase wages if that's what it takes to get the staff they need. There's already a law that prohibits multiple employers from colluding to reduce that competition.
Re:Maybe the Gig Economy Isn’t Reshaping Work After All by s73v3r_ on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:48PM (#17270352)
"Are individuals incapable of making decisions on their own?"

You must not think so if you believe they shouldn't have the ability to join a union.

"Nobody is forced to drive"

This whole "nobody is forced to" meme loses any and all credibility once you think for 2 seconds and realize that people are forced to work or starve.

"Let supply and demand work."

We're not the ones stopping it from working; employers are.