News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by ohazi on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:44PM (#17258241)
I find it hilarious that a CA company is leading the charge in new, efficient, high-quality pre-fab design and construction. These units are going to improve construction quality and lower costs in every state except CA, thanks to our asinine zoning laws.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by oftenwrong on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:07PM (#17261486)
The same problems are pretty much everywhere in the US. This brings to mind a proposed project in Boston that faced a lot of friction, in part because prefab construction was proposed:

https://www.universalhub.com/2016/lagrange-street-residents-...

>The Zoning Board of Appeals this week rejected a proposed condo building on the site of a former asthma-inhaler factory in West Roxbury, citing neighborhood concerns about density, parking and the developer's proposal to assemble prefab modular units on the site, rather than hiring local workers for more traditional construction.

>...

>But board member Mark Erlich, who is also executive secretary and treasurer of the New England Regional Council of Carpenters, used the proposed modular construction to open an attack on the project. City officials have frequently expressed skepticism of such prefab units being bolted together, he said. But he added:

>It also removes a lot of [work] hours that could be done by people who live and work in the city vs. people in Maine, who wear sneakers.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by chrisseaton on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:49PM (#17261681)
What's the relevant of 'who wear sneakers'?

It seems so orthogonal that I think it must be some kind of local joke?

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by jmalicki on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:32PM (#17261865)
They’re not wearing steel toed boots, therefore aren’t real respectable tradespeople.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by jt2190 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:20PM (#17261818)
It's likely an allegation of lax worker safety, i.e. the workers should wear safety (a.k.a "steel toe") boots.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by cocacola1 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:28PM (#17261854)
Perhaps he's trying to structure it as "Those people from Maine are going to take our jobs."
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by maire on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:05PM (#17259708)
We just built a "hybrid" house in Santa Cruz county. We picked the default design and stuck to it. We had to make a few changes to get through the planning department. The biggest issue was not at the building level - but rather everything they made us do to prepare the site for building. Yikes - that was expensive. It also took a long time to get through the planning department.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by digikata on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:12PM (#17260779)
Was more required of the site prep for the hybrid house than one using more typical construction processes?
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by maire on Friday June 08, 2018 @08:12AM (#17264514)
The site prep was normal for any house. The biggest change was in septic system requirements. Septic systems cost three times as much as they did a few years ago because we have to have an active system with a fan and they have to have lifetime inspections. The contractor said this is normal now for the state of California. There are also relatively new rules to manage water runoff.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by anoncoward111 on Friday June 08, 2018 @08:19AM (#17264565)
Does your town/city also ban composting toilets?

I wanted to buy a $60,000 foreclosure in my town-- they told me I'm not allowed to even step foot on the property until I install a septic system.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by maire on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:41AM (#17265214)
I don't know. The county was reviewing composting toilets in 2013. I don't know the outcome.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by anoncoward111 on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:44AM (#17265251)
Many of the counties in the Northeast have taken a strong stance against composting toilets. It's because the local construction companies control the local governments here.

They literally don't let you buy or move onto specific properties without submitting plans from "an approved septic installation company."

You can imagine who is on the approval board, and which companies are "approved providers."

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by maire on Friday June 08, 2018 @10:23AM (#17265656)
California has water issues - that is why they were seriously considering composting toilets.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by anoncoward111 on Friday June 08, 2018 @10:33AM (#17265783)
Sounds like I should move there :) The Northeast's justification is that they don't want human feces in the water table.

But their policies don't reflect this noble goal.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by Iv on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:18PM (#17262047)
"leading the charge"? In the US maybe, but the world has not waited for them.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/video/2015/apr/30/china-bu...

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by tomjakubowski on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:54PM (#17258968)
What are the state zoning laws? As far as I know, the state constitution leaves zoning as an issue for the cities/counties to handle. Is that your beef or are there laws on the books I'm ignorant of?
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by bobthepanda on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:02PM (#17260694)
The issue is that regional concerns (there is not enough housing in the region) do not mesh well with local control. Every locality thinks that everyone else should relieve the burden of housing because they are already "crowded" and new residents mean more money needed for services, which is a hard ask in a place like CA where raising local taxes is fiendishly difficult.

If all the localities in a region, or even most of them, act this way, the end result is a housing shortage even when the economy is barely chugging along.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by njoro on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:49PM (#17261055)
Personally I wouldn't mind the Bay Area looking like Shenzhen, but I don't understand why people think that anything is going to change. Housing and education are prime assets in the new information based society and economy. People aren't going to share that anymore than natural resources, stocks, bitcoins or domains. Regardless of the larger consequences.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by adrianratnapala on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:40PM (#17261643)
> People aren't going to share ...

It's more complicated than just sharing.

It's not about whether you have to let people come and live on your own property. It's about whether your neighbour may subdivide her own property for a profit. Collectively, owners have an incentive to stop her; but individual incentives are mixed.

We can see how the politics of that tension is working out right now. But how can anyone tell how it will play out in the future?

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday June 07, 2018 @07:13PM (#17261202)
Also, Shenzhen isn’t much cheaper either (at least to buy, rents are much more reasonable of course).
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by DrScump on Friday June 08, 2018 @04:35AM (#17263621)

  CA where raising local taxes is fiendishly difficult
The vast majority of local tax increase attempts (sales tax add-ons, parcel taxes) over the past few decades passed, and on the first try.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by vkou on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:58PM (#17261124)
> Every locality thinks that everyone else should relieve the burden of housing because they are already "crowded" and new residents mean more money needed for services, which is a hard ask in a place like CA where raising local taxes is fiendishly difficult.

The localities have a point. Why should existing residents pay for new infrastructure, to accommodate housing for 10,000 new residents (All because large tech firms keep building offices in the valley?)

In a proper world, either the tech giant, or those new employees should pay for those infrastructure improvements.

Traditionally, this has been done through high re-zoning and subdivision fees.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by d1zzy on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:31PM (#17261585)
Aren't local tech companies offices paying taxes that should take care of that? Unless you mean that tech companies should build private roads and infrastructure which sounds very bad... The way you get money from private parties and use it to build public infrastructure is through taxes :)
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by ThrustVectoring on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:38PM (#17261886)
Tech company office taxes incentivize local municipalities to open offices, not to build houses. And in fact that's exactly what happens - offices go up, but the people to work there have to commute in from outside the municipality.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday June 07, 2018 @11:25PM (#17262357)
Seems the solution is to have mixed use high rises.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by vkou on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:58PM (#17261728)
Because tax rates are the same for old, and new residents/employers, they aren't paying enough to offset the costs they are adding to the system.

If you and your 4 roommates rent a 5-bedroom house... And then a sixth person moves in, and demands that everyone spends $20,000 each, to construct a sixth bedroom... The old residents are getting a pretty bad deal. The new resident paid $20,000 to get a room... But the rest of the house paid $100,000, for no benefit to themselves.

Cities have zoning/subdivision fees to deal with this exact problem. If you're adding X new units to the city, you have to pay for the infrastructure to support these X units.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by jdavis703 on Friday June 08, 2018 @01:10AM (#17262736)
The reason you're getting downvoted is because your facts are wrong, property tax is lower for older residents because Prop 13 limits increases in assessed value. Further new projects are saddled with a wide variety of impact fees. Overall new residents wind up subsdising old residents.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by DrScump on Friday June 08, 2018 @07:53PM (#17270671)

  property tax is lower for older residents
That's incorrect as written. Perhaps you meant to say that "for otherwise equal properties, tax is lower for owners with longer tenure in that property." It has nothing to do with owner age.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by ajmurmann on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:44PM (#17262177)
Are you serious?! If your area gets more desirable and built up your property value will more than make up for any perceived tax unfairness. If you end up blocking a lot in Manhattan with your single family home you are a made man!
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by jimrandomh on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:00PM (#17259029)
Yes, the problematic zoning laws exist mainly at the city level. The problem is that the decisions about key areas are being made by people who are incentivized to make housing prices go up (because they own property), which they do by severely restricting construction of dense housing.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by ajmurmann on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:50PM (#17262199)
Even that seems super short sighed though isn't it? If an area turns into the next Manhattan all land owners win big time. I'd love it if it became economically desirable to build a 100 story skyscraper next to my house and someone went ahead and did it!
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by baybal2 on Friday June 08, 2018 @10:50AM (#17265954)
This idea is entirely alien to majority of American high class suburbians.

My sorries to people insulted by this statement.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by JohnnyConatus on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:06PM (#17259106)
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by patja on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:16PM (#17259200)
Where in that AMA is there a reference to zoning being defined at the state level? I did not see it in the long starting post.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by ucaetano on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:24PM (#17259282)
ohazi never talked about zoning laws being defined at the State level. Just that zoning laws in CA are asinine.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by jpao79 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:02PM (#17259059)
Actually its driven by the need for localized labor and unfortunately due to high housing costs, labor can't afford to live in downtown SF/LA and so a lot of time is wasted getting to the job site from the outer suburbs.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by ucaetano on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:26PM (#17259321)
> unfortunately due to high housing costs

And housing costs are high because of asinine zoning laws, as OP mentioned.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by jpao79 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:44PM (#17259521)
Ok true. Just would add that high housing costs are actually the sum of asinine zoning laws + high labor costs and that high labor costs are due to high housing costs. :)
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by branchless on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:52PM (#17259597)
Nope. In urban areas land is undersupplied therefore you will be paying the "monopoly price" where you bid what you can afford.

So if a building used to cost 400k, broken into 200k land cost and 200k building cost, it will still cost 400k, 300k land cost and 100k building cost.

That's how prices are set. It's not "how much this costs to build plus a fair profit".

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by ohazi on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:57PM (#17260192)
The zoning and permitting regulations prevent you from building reasonably on land that you already own. There are plenty of wealthy individuals and developers in San Francisco who would love to tear down two or three shabby Victorian houses to put up a five-story 20-unit condo if they could only get the project approved.

San Francisco in particular makes it extremely easy for neighborhood residents to impede projects that would be automatically approved in any other city [1, 2]. This is why nothing gets built here, it has nothing to do with the cost of land.

No developer can afford to put up with a five-year battle with neighbors who complain about the shadow that the new building will cast onto their back yard, or to pay for fifteen $X0,000 bullshit environmental studies that the city will make the developer conduct as a "compromise." And remember, these are for designs that are completely up to code and that are zoned legally.

[1]: https://sf.curbed.com/2013/4/17/10252934/what-the-heck-is-di...

[2]: https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/nevius/article/Discretionary-...

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by branchless on Thursday June 07, 2018 @05:33PM (#17260477)
Zoning isn't going to fix all of this for you. It's highly unlikely supply will ramp up to avoid bidding at the monopoly price.
Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by rictic on Thursday June 07, 2018 @07:47PM (#17261366)
> to avoid bidding at the monopoly price.

Can you expand on this? What's the monopoly of?

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by branchless on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:17PM (#17262042)
No more land can be manufactured, supply is inelastic. In urban areas you are going to have to bid against everyone else and the highest bidder, who agrees to work for the most years for the land, wins.

Rezoning isn't going to fix this IMHO. It might help, but you will reach a limit and then have the same root cause to deal with: rentiers.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by derefr on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:00PM (#17259652)
I don't think anyone would be using one of these pre-fab buildings for gentrifying existing urban centers. Those development projects usually aim to create aspirational purchases, or investment properties—neither of which wants the taint of "put together from parts, like a trailer-home or something."

No, I imagine these would mostly be used to construct "condo-cities": exurbs/farmland "reformatted" all at once into new urban branch-nodes by plopping five hundred mixed-use condo buildings onto it, and then connecting it to the nearest urban center using high-speed rail or other public transit.

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by majormajor on Thursday June 07, 2018 @05:31PM (#17260461)
> Those development projects usually aim to create aspirational purchases, or investment properties—neither of which wants the taint of "put together from parts, like a trailer-home or something."

Live in a few of them and you'll see that the level of build quality can be wildly divorced from appearance and sales messaging. :)

Re:Developers are manufacturing prefabricated apartment buil... by beamatronic on Friday June 08, 2018 @02:02AM (#17262972)
The whole state? Isn’t there any county that is development friendly?