News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by danesparza on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:28PM (#17257366)
I'd like to point out this article consistently uses the word 'wealth'. I take this to mean all assets owned, including cash assets.

Let that sink in a while.

That would include vehicles, houses, clothes, everything.

I am musing on this problem from my air conditioned office at work. We truly have first world problems.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Matt3o12_ on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:35PM (#17257455)
But does this also include negative wealth? Especially in the US, it seems to me that many people have a lot of debt – staring from credit card debt to a too expensive car lease (and a new one ever 3 years) to the house they have payments on for ~50 years? This way, it seems to me that a lot of people (especially younger ones) have a wealth of ~-10,000€.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:38PM (#17257492)
Debt is “bad” when used for depreciating assets (cars, credit cards). Debt is “good” when used as leverage on appreciating assets (real estate) or working assets (tools, business vehicles, servers, or anything else being used to generate cash flow).

If I have an interest only loan on something like a taxi medallions (thanks Planet Money for the example!), I generate cash flow with that asset, and can walk away from the debt at any time through bankruptcy of the owning entity, that’s still positive wealth (cash flow).

The less capital you need to obtain access to greater amounts of cash flow, the better the cash on cash return/investment quality.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Matt3o12_ on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:50PM (#17257634)
But real estate debt is only good if you can afford it and you buy smart. I know a lot of people who bought a house and sold it later for less even after all the payments because they bought it high and sold it low.

Furthermore, if you pay for something very long, you are also going to be paying a lot of interest. You wouldn’t be paying that long if you could afford it and you would be getting a better credit rate if you could afford it.

Unfortunately not everybody is able to invest smartly and thus good debt easily becomes bad debt. It doesn’t help that most people potray reale estates as good debt because they really aren’t that good unless you know what you are doing.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by shaggerty on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:12PM (#17258545)
Even if your house ends up being less than you bought it for you still have a house. Assuming you want to live in the same area long term it seems wiser to finish a mortgage and be left with a house that's worth less than you paid for it versus paying rent for the same amount of time and ending up with nothing.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by astura on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:38PM (#17258816)
I think you're ignoring the significant carrying costs of a house. My house last year had over $11,000 in carrying costs in just taxes, insurance,and interest. Never minding the upkeep and repairs (which are significant yet difficult to estimate). There's other hidden costs like opportunity cost, the return on investment you'd be getting if you didn't have that money tied up in your house.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:49PM (#17258925)
Houses have almost always kept ahead of inflation, and carrying expenses replace rent.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by astura on Thursday June 07, 2018 @02:51PM (#17258941)
Read the post I'm replying to, we're talking about a house that went DOWN in value.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:36PM (#17259448)
I did. It’s extremely rare for real estate to decline in value, and walking away from the property is always an option if it has (or a short sale, which is must less detrimental on your credit).
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by astura on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:30PM (#17260918)
Even if it were true (and it's not[1]), the topic at hand is a hypothetical case where "your house ends up being less than you bought it" and that's what I was directly replying to. If you lose money on the sale price is (almost certainly) not even close to the amount of money you have to spend just to own the house.

[1] I personally know at least three people who sold houses for less than the bought them 7-10 years later. My parents have owned their house for 25 years and while the dollar value went up it hasn't kept pace with inflation (recently got three appraisals) even though they have cared for it and even added an extra bathroom.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:38PM (#17260037)
> It’s extremely rare for real estate to decline in value

You and I must have very different ideas of what the word "extremely" means.

> walking away from the property is always an option

That is only true in twelve states. In the other 38, the lender can sue you to recover the difference between the house's value and what you owe even after they foreclose.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 07, 2018 @05:02PM (#17260242)
As I mention above, you need to do your due diligence. Investing without knowing the rules is fraught with peril.

I only use non-recourse mortgages when investing in real estate. YMMV.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:57PM (#17261111)
The mere fact that you are looking at real estate as an investment rather than as a place to live indicates that you have far more financial resources than a typical person. For a typical person it is not a realistic option to discard their entire social network and move halfway across the country just to get some more favorable mortgage laws.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 07, 2018 @09:19PM (#17261810)
You don't have to live somewhere with non-recourse mortgages. To get started, you only need 3% down, an FHA mortgage, and a 4-plex that cashflows slightly. You then eventually refi that with something more conventional and move on to your next property.

Real estate is only one investment vehicle where you don't need a large amount of capital to realize substantial cash flows. Whenever possible, seek out leverage opportunities.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by TheCoelacanth on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:35AM (#17265148)
You don't get to choose where you are born or grow up. You are effectively suggesting that people move a thousand miles away from every single person that they know just to get more favorable mortgage laws. That is not doable without starting from a position of privilege.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by JoeAltmaier on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:40AM (#17265195)
As investment, you don't actually have to live where you are buying. I have a relative 2000 miles away that buys condos in my city as investments. My wife researches them, reports back and they make a buying decision. There's a favorable situation here and they're taking advantage of it. Not by 'privilege'; by smart investing.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by TheCoelacanth on Friday June 08, 2018 @10:55AM (#17266008)
If you can afford to buy a house that you aren't even living in, you have far more financial resources than the vast majority of people. You seem to be completely deluded about how much a normal person can afford to put into investments.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by astura on Friday June 08, 2018 @11:17AM (#17266255)
The average person probably shouldn't be buying investment properties anyways. Running income producing properties is more of a part time job than anything else. It takes significant effort to find the right property at the right price with the right renovations in order to make a good profit. Unless you're really willing to put in the leg work (and usually the "sweat equity"), you're better off putting your money in index funds or REITs. It takes the right person to make money in real estate.

I've known several people who wanted to "get into real estate" so they bought duplexes and became landlords. All of them lost money or broke even because they went into it without doing their due diligence. My parents ended up just walking away from their "investment" property and declaring bankruptcy, that's how much they lost out. It isn't buy property -> profit like people think.

Leverage cuts both ways - it magnifies both gains and losses.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by shoo on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:37PM (#17260031)
It depends. On parameters like interest rates and rates of return on other asset classes and rental prices and inflation. There is opportunity cost - in some circumstances paying cheap rent and investing the difference into other investment asset classes might leave you better off in the long run. See the New York Times rent vs buy thing.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by mi100hael on Thursday June 07, 2018 @05:35PM (#17260501)
I think a lot of people incorrectly view personal residences as investments. They don't produce income and their valuation is tied largely to comps which really translates to other peoples' feelings and purchasing power at that time. Mortgaging a home is arguably a poor use of debt unless you're actually able to put a similar sum to work making a higher return elsewhere.

If you're investing in real estate by purchasing a cash-flowing property like apartments, then you'd be crazy not to use leverage. You can easily calculate your ROI based on property cashflow and projected value based on rent growth. And your ROI is always going to be bigger if you only put up 25% of the value and let the bank pay for the rest as long as you're cashflowing more than the mortgage payments.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by AdamM12 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:59PM (#17257732)
Personally don't view this as a necessarily bad thing. Short term losses like this suck but what you learn long term is entirely more valuable than if you did well the first time. Nothing teaches you as well as losing money.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by OscarCunningham on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:49PM (#17257620)
The probably count mortgages and student loans as negative wealth, and they probably count houses as positive wealth, but they probably don't count degrees as positive wealth even though they should.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by isostatic on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:01PM (#17257754)
Certainly a good educattion is a massive value, but it's not something you can sell - like a house or a car.

Your health is also of massive value, and indeed is something you can sell -- a healthy kidney alone is worth $250k.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by shoo on Thursday June 07, 2018 @04:44PM (#17260087)
I would wager that the market value of selling one's own organs (or their replacement cost) is not accounted for in this study.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by rukittenme on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:53PM (#17257663)
You have to define "wealth" if you want a worthwhile answer. After all, debt is a component of a person's assets.

If you remember your accounting courses: assets are equal to the sum of all liabilities and equity. Meaning mortgage debt and home equity combine to form your total home assets. A person may have $1m in assets and $900k in liabilities. Or a person could have $200k in assets but $50k in liabilities. Which person is more "wealthy".

I suppose its a matter of opinion because, after all, we haven't defined a goal. Is a low debt to equity ratio desirable? Depends on what you're trying to accomplish. Is high cash flow desirable? As an end state, yes that's desirable but what if that end state requires a large amount of debt to achieve?

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by zulln on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:50PM (#17257632)
> to the house they have payments on for ~50 years

Yeah, but the house itself is most likely worth at least the same as the loan.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by twblalock on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:26PM (#17258031)
Unfortunately the link from the article to the original report seems to be broken.

The standard simple calculation for net worth is assets minus debts, so credit card debt, mortgages, etc. would be negative.

But even though the mortgage is negative, the value of the home would be positive, and the net difference between the value of the home and the debt owed on the mortgage could very well be a positive component of net worth.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by djrogers on Thursday June 07, 2018 @01:09PM (#17257848)
> the house they have payments on for ~50 years?

Is that really a thing? Do many people really go beyond the standard 30 year term of their mortgages?

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by aggie on Friday June 08, 2018 @11:23AM (#17266330)
I don't know anything about the frequency, but if you refinance you can start the 30 year process over. So if you refi after 20 years and go for the 30 year loan you'd be at 50.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by eanzenberg on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:38PM (#17257501)
Yeah but, who's happier? That's not easy to answer btw. I've read studies that show evidence for both: -Money brings you happiness (up to some asymptote most never reach) -Poor (by western standards) rural tribes or hunter-gatherers are very happy.

I think it's illustrative to compare assets across the world but perhaps a more normalized metric would be overall "happiness", whatever that means (no its not easy to define).

My own western-biased experience tells me it's a bit of both. Money does in fact bring freedom of time which can bring happiness, but I've met some extremely happy people living on peanuts, eating very healthy and living on islands off the coast of Japan.

Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by evanpw on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:50PM (#17257630)
It would be completely consistent for more money => more happiness for each individual person, but for differences in happiness between people to be dominated by non-monetary factors (personality, relationships, local culture, etc.). The problem is that you probably can't make that hunter-gatherer much richer without completely changing the culture they live in.
Re:Half of all adults in the world have less than $2,300 in ... by Retra on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:17PM (#17262044)
Happiness isn't a useful metric by itself. Happiness needs to be stable, stability requires power, and power requires relative wealth. In the long run inequality undermines happiness, even if you've met some happy poor people.

Look at the native American population. They were happy until the weren't: when a culture with greater financial power wanted what they had and they didn't have the power to stop it.

Or look at Somali pirates: happy fisherman. Until foreign powers dump waste in their fishing waters for decades, then they lose their economy and have to arm themselves to defend their waters. No more happy. Because they couldn't fund a proper navy.

The point being -- know the difference between weather and climate.