News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google faces EU antitrust fine over Android case by detaro on Thursday June 07, 2018 @11:16AM (#17256512)
Apple is free to not sell their OS to others. The app store could be problematic due to conflicts with Apple apps, similar to the Android issue, but does Apple dominate any market? Maybe one could construct a case if Apple dominates spending on digital media or something (Apple customers are often cited as spending more money), but even then it's kind of awkward that it's a minority of devices.

Google on the other hand clearly has the largest market share for phone OSes and uses that share to push other products.

Re:Google faces EU antitrust fine over Android case by macintux on Thursday June 07, 2018 @11:28AM (#17256647)
I very much enjoyed the "Apple has a monopoly on iOS devices" argument I heard in a different thread.

Apple has a monopoly on its business model, and on the willingness to eliminate legacy hardware mechanisms. Good luck finding a legal case for an abuse of either of those.

Re:Google faces EU antitrust fine over Android case by MBCook on Thursday June 07, 2018 @11:40AM (#17256810)
Until I can buy a Whirlpool washer from from Maytag or Ford has to sell me a brand new ‘57 Mustang the Justice Department isn’t doing their job. /s

Always interesting to see the arguments people come up with on the internet to justify their position on some other issue.

Re:Google faces EU antitrust fine over Android case by mikhailt on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:11PM (#17257153)
Their business model isn't illegal, so there is no need to find any legal case.

You're now implying all manufacturers are abusers of their own monopoly.

Xbox games only runs on Xbox, MS should be charged the same way as Apple here.

Sony for Playstation.

Nintendo for Wii.

Etc.

Apple created iOS, just as MS, Sony and other companies. They have the ultimate control over it.

iOS is NOT a public platform nor does it belong to be people. People have no entitlement to anything from Apple in this case. You don't like it, just don't buy it.

Android is an open system, thus where the anti-trust starts to kick in quicker for Google than other companies because Google is demanding something that they have no ownership of. Forcing Android OEMs to use Google services in order to use some parts of Android that supposed to be available to everyone?

Re:Google faces EU antitrust fine over Android case by macintux on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:57PM (#17257709)
You're violently agreeing with me.
Re:Google faces EU antitrust fine over Android case by mikhailt on Thursday June 07, 2018 @06:24PM (#17260871)
Ah, my apologies, I’ve misread what you’ve said at the end there. It sounded like you’re saying there’s no legal justification.

I didn’t mean for it to sound violently but maybe I shouldn’t reply on HN too early in the morning.

I wish I could delete my post after a few hours.

Re:Google faces EU antitrust fine over Android case by macintux on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:40PM (#17262157)
No biggie. My phrasing could have been better: when I start to get sarcastic I rarely state my case clearly.