I assume people would very move quickly to get the speed limits changed to a number that represents the actual maximum speed you can go before receiving a ticket, rather than the vague percentage/luck combo that it is now.
For example, If there are so many laws that everyone is always doing something illegal all the time, then a corrupt cop can stop anyone he wants to at any time, because they've got to be guilty of something. It's a reason for types of deregulation, and keeping law slim in general.
When police have to overlook a large amount of activity that violates the law, something is wrong with the law.
And it develops for the same reasons: in a complex system there's going to be all sorts of weird corner cases, and some of them are bad, so you write some more code/laws to deal with those outcomes ...
Not just "ADD MORE LINES OF CODE", which you make sound is like some concrete reality of how things always get done. It's not. And no one should strive to do things this way.
In other words, growing complexity of the system to deal with new cases is past of least resistance.
Who is refactoring this law code? No one. It gets written once and stands forever. It gets repealed once and a while, but it doesn't get actively refactored.
Many of the laws on the books are there due to lobbying, not logic, reason or need. Some are based on moral outrage to propaganda, some are due to businesses wanting greater leverage of their market and greater control over the entry-barrier. Many laws are totally unconstitutional but remain because someone must be successfully challenged which is hard when the law is meant to target the homeless guy you just don't like sitting on your corner who wouldn't have the means to hire a proper attorney.
I think what the original poster was getting at is that AI enforcement, with a broken legal system is a recipe for abuse and injustice.
The entire idea of selective enforceability is an affront to the concept of justice.
I've had my car searched for drugs by police in Arizona without cause other than they thought I "appeared to be on drugs" due to the fact they made me stand outside in the snow for 10 minutes while questioning me during a bogus traffic stop and I eventually started to shiver. I was driving through AZ on my way from Colorado to California... two places recreational marijuana are perfectly legal (by state standards) yet if they would have found even the smallest amount of weed in my car even if someone else had just dropped it somewhere (they check literally everywhere -- including rifling through my tea bags with their dirty paws), I would have been in jail on felony charges.
Granted I made sure my car was immaculate because I know how insane the people of AZ are when it comes to "criminal justice" and all it cost me was an hour of travel time. But the fact remains that there is no presumed consistency in law and felonies are a big deal and have consequences that reach far beyond some localized legal affair.
I have known people who have picked up felonies because they were doing something innocuous beside being in the wrong place at the wrong time. And when we start talking about AI enforcement, it's a scary concept because a felony means that for instance you could be picked up on federal firearm charges because some program found a slingshot in a picture of your bedroom on Facebook which gave them cause to issue a warrant to raid your house. And then you aren't able to flee the country because you can't just walk down to Mexico like you used to be able to because of the AI surveillance.
Taking the high-horse and saying people should trust in the system and just do their duty as citizens is great and all, but that type of ignorance is also why we have the highest prison population in the world. People who could be benefiting society even if only marginally, who are forced to be strictly welfare cases.
Not to mention, this isn't solving any problem - just opening the door to a bunch of new potential problems, so what's the point, other than lining the pocket of some random government contractor who probably lobbied for the tech in the first place? This is inane.
The result?
Expectation: A government that wants to adapt good technology and morally acceptable ways to have a great sociey.
Reality: A big company that "tricked" the government into thinking they will reach their expectation, when really they're just attempting to drain the government for its money, as well establish somekind of "power" in the society.
Having said that, I guess all that happens is statutory law remains simple, but case law grows more complex as the body of judicial decisions grows? What we seem to be missing is a "refactoring" process to periodically rewrite statutory law to replace bloat in case law with a more otimised statute. Like coders, politicians prefer to work on shiny new features than maintaining existing features?
Oh my god HN... Laws are typically written with a lot of vague language because humans operate in vague, gray areas. If you write an entirely prescriptive set of laws (Like Hammurabi's Code of Laws) you will forget some things, be too draconian in others, and overall a sense of justice will be lost.
Lets say the same law says something is illegal and not doing something is illegal, because of some convoluted language and whoever passed the law missed it. Maybe not refactor right away, but at least check for errors.
Also, if a computer could process law code, lawyers would be obsolete, patent trolls wouldn't have leverage, etc etc.
The truth is that fundamentally law is not deterministic. You can't deterministically apply the reasonable person standard, or even the layman standard. How do you handle the expanse of human nature, and it's intricacies and vagaries?
Law can't be perfectly deterministic because life is not deterministic given the constraint of free will. Trying to make an idealized code without human judgement (and yes, that exposes human bias as well) results in the worst kind of law - an autocracy.
What I'm suggesting is computers to take the logic of law code to poke around, tracing logic around and finding the obvious logical inconsistencies. A goal would be reducing law code as well as making it more laymen readable.
Obviously a huge benefit of being judged by humans and peers is a sense of mercy. I'm not saying we should mess with that. Also, I would say that anything the computer found would be a suggestion to congress as a way to refactor law, not trusting the computer to automatically do it.
A lot of the dumb laws where mercy is frequently allowed are that way because they were designed to be, as catch-alls for harder to define grievances. An AI 'judge' just needs to understand what it means to be a good person.
Of course then that could be expanded to an AI which simply tallies moral points and for which a given person committing a given crime gets a punishment designed to best rehabilitate them not to commit the crime again. But that would also be a system which is judge jury and executioner and not even human, and has some self-designed ultimate moral code...thats a lot to get right, and a lot to go wrong.
> I'm betting in 5 years we'll see lawyers use AI to help them do their job, specifically to help them create logical arguments for their cases.
So, actually, Lawyers are using AI right now - but not in that way. Specifically AI is used to analyze and bring up relevant case law, in the same way a law clerk might. It's not perfect, it still requires humans to clean up, but it saves some hours since it can analyze a lot of law quickly and vaguely run a likelihood analysis.
Law is also in English. English is not formally logical. Frequently laws have subtle wording problems.
I've heard this hypothesized as a means to remove legislative bloat, but where has it actually been implemented?
started as 2:1 https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/01/trumps-...
6 months in, it was actually more like 16:1 https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/trump-kills-16-regulation...
I think I heard recently it's more like 24:1.
Law in its writing and interpretation is less deterministic, and quantity of statute is far less of a factor in its complexity than most in STEM realise.
Further, to parse law in a sense that it could be sensibly refactored, would be impossible with AI/ML as the field stands today, and I think will never be possible.
I think someone should make AI to refactor law code into 1/1000 its current size. There are like millions of lines of law, even for stuff like soybean farming. I'm sure a lot of that is duplicitous, redundant legal speak, not a precise computer-type language.