What's at issue in this situation isn't the size of the stake in the company you own, but rather the fact that (say) Rackspace agreed to do business with your company and not you. For you to be on the hook for Rackspace/Company debts, Rackspace will have to convince a court that both you and Rackspace had an understanding that you were the one making a hosting agreement. Against that will be the fact that they invoiced your company, accepted payments for your company, signed a contract with your company, and that the service they provided was used solely for your company.
Since companies go out of business all the time, my guess is that this never happens. Why would Rackspace waste time going after company debts when 99% of the time they'll never see a dime, and, on occasion, may risk legal action themselves by bringing frivolous lawsuits?
There are situations where you can slip up and obligate yourself to your company's creditors; if you Google, you'll find out for instance that in Iowa you want to be very careful about how your company's checks are layed out and signed. But it is not the case that "if you just slapped something together on Bizfilings.com you're probably not protected". Generally, for contacts: limited liability corporation is a limited liability corporation.
This makes perfect sense. Incorporation isn't the secret trick for conduct risk-free confidence jobs on people. You can't incorporate, sell Springfield the sham monorail, and skip town scot-free. Obviously, if your company is a criminal enterprise, all bets are off. On the other hand, the laws that provide alter ego liability aren't the secret key to unlocking corporate liability shields.
Since (a) the poster's company almost certainly wasn't a fraud, and (b) most companies that fail also aren't likely to be frauds, and (c) it is prohibitively expensive to attempt to prove in court that a company was a fraud, and (d) most of the officers of small startup companies aren't going to be in a position to pay at the end of a court battle, none of this matters.
Also: note how little of this has anything to do with how many shares the guy owns.
We are seriously geeking out here over something that isn't relevant to this guy's problem. Companies go out of business all the time; the company owners do not as a matter of course lose their houses!
You're talking about spending 25 grand to recover three.
I know, that's even weirder.
> I'm just saying that if his creditors want to pursue him personally for the debt they do have the law on their side.
Sorry, but I really don't buy that. In theory, maybe, in practice, knowing what I know about this situation so far, no way.
edit: man I hate it when people delete their presence from a thread like that, Paul please stop that from being possible.
It's also not relevant to your Internet startup owing Rackspace hosting charges.
Without starting everything up again, I'll just mention that the ability to pierce the veil depends some on which state you are set up in (pharma investors nearly insist on Deleware, FWIW).
The whole point of incorporating is to provide protection to persons in this exact situation.
That may be a harsh example.
Business is still about people. Regardless of whether an individual's credit it tied to the company - and in this case I believe it is - these decisions affect his future ability to conduct business. These decisions affect his relationships with other people.
Telling everyone to take a hike may be a short-term solution. However, I believe finding a win-win solution among all parties is a long-term win.
It most certainly does shield you from personal liability for debts the company incurred in good faith (meaning: virtually all the company's debts).
People on this thread are giving what seems to me to be some spectacularly bad advice. Do not throw your own personal finances down the toilet after your company's.
The corporation could file for bankruptcy and possibly the bankruptcy court could sort it all out, which sounds like the best thing for those involved.
These things are not related.
Thomas' advice may sound harsh but it is absolutely the most realistic approach here, he has to think about #1 for a bit and divorce himself from identifying corporate debt with private debt. He technically doesn't owe anybody anything as far as I can see and by assuming responsibility might actually make matters worse (because he is now at least acting as a signing officer of the company).
I had a stake in a Canadian gas station, the lady that ran it had signed up for some stupid carpet cleaning machine that they were paying through the nose for. She was complaining about how much it had cost and how many years they would still be under contract, it would have cost about 50 times what the p.o.s. was worth.
So I asked for permission to negotiate a solution, received it and called the company. I presented them with two options, $100 to buy out the contract (and keep the machine) or a very protracted collection procedure with 0 chance of success and a very large amount of bad publicity. The one phone call was all it took.
Business is not always being nice, and in this case the OP is being way too nice and is not looking out for his own interests as much as he should. The fact that his co-founder left him to rot is particularly galling.
Oh, and I think you meant 'wouldn't', not 'would'.
First, one is a criminal offence, and the other is most certainly not.
The act of incorporating is exactly the act of replacing personal responsibility with that of the corporation. He isn't even a majority owner.
Don't take out a loan. Don't restructure your debts. Don't negotiate with your creditors. Don't sell your car. Don't take a loan from your parents. Don't incur anything more than nominal legal bills.
Collect your contracts and take them immediately to your personal attorney and have them reviewed before you attach your own personal credit to your business'. Doing so is almost certainly unnecessary. You are probably just fine.
You are a businessperson, but you're not thinking like one, and you are going to get screwed. When your company's creditors worked out contracts with your business, they understood that they were assuming the risk that the company might go out of business and be unable to pay. That risk was priced into your contract terms.
If people you've done business with are now telling you that you should stake your personal finances on the debts of your company, then, absent some poorly thought out up-front agreement you had with those vendors to the contrary, you're being taken advantage of. Perhaps we'd benefit from hearing more about who those people are.
As for the merchant account: well, the people saying you could be blacklisted sure sound credible, and maybe you should listen to them. But please also note that there are people on this thread saying you should sell your car or take out a loan to satisfy someone else's debts, and take all the advice you get here with a big grain of salt. It shouldn't cost more than a couple hundred dollars to have an attorney explain to you (not your company, not your cofounder) that you are almost certainly not liable for thousands of dollars of company debts.