I bought my sister some bluetooth Etymotics which are no longer made. She really liked those. I also have an Ety.com headset, which is really good at what it does. (Allows you to have a phone conversation in really noisy environments.)
My advice: try some from a store with a really good return policy. They are not for everyone. Also, I'd just buy the ER4's, unless you want an iPhone headset. They are a very good in-ear phone with superb isolation, especially if you are sitting still, and you can use them to do serious sound work.
I've bought mine from http://www.headphone.com/. (Not affiliated with them in any way.)
I (apparently) have rather large ear canals, and a lot of in-ears don't seal properly. I've had the worst luck with the triple-flange style. As such, I kind of need something with larger sizes than normal, and / or get something custom molded (which I'm seriously considering). Know a good place to look for any of that?
Grados, on the other hand, are full of gooey retro goodness: http://www.gradolabs.com/product_pages/rs1.htm I have an 80, and it's amazing how many random music geeks will start talking to you just because you have them on.
Since you've used some: have a recommended starting point for Etymotics? I've been looking for something isolating to complement the I-can-hear-that-ant-tapdancing-through-my-music of the Grados.