News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unofficial alternative UI of hackernews by futuremint on Friday September 24, 2010 @10:23AM (#1723711)
The very first thing I tried to do was click on the words "comments" and "points" to sort the entries by that column.

Placing those columns on the left-hand side gives them the highest importance. Is that the intention of this UI?

Re:Unofficial alternative UI of hackernews by wvl on Friday September 24, 2010 @02:18PM (#1724689)
I can understand why you thought they would be sortable. However, it's designed around being a chronological list. When I want to scan the higher rated stories, I use the filter links -- top 10, top 20, top 50%. Sorting by points or comments does make some sense, however, it is also a function of how long a story has been posted -- so I don't really think a javascript sort in place would be too useful.

As for the UI design -- I wanted a simple list of stories that I could scan, plus I wanted to be able to see the points and number of comments associated with that story. While I understand your point about highest importance, if I had placed the numbers on the right the ragged right nature of the text would make it hard to scan.