News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop?

Tried using iPad Pro 10.5 for a few weeks as a walkabout machine but it’s driving me a bit nuts. Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? Basically maps onto MacBook, MacBook Pro 13, MacBook Pro 15. I have a desktop I use for heavy lifting.

What’s the argument against the 2 lb MacBook? Or is the 13” the “just right” between the “too small” and the “too big”?

( 9 comments | 3 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by saluki on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:46PM (#17234049)
I would go with a macbook air, it's super solid quality wise and a great walkabout. Macbook pro's keyboards are failing left and right. Wait till they sort that out and then think about a pro.
Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by mchannon on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @03:05AM (#17235536)
We don't know about your use case, style, tolerance for real estate, or eyesight quality, but think of how the appliance is going to be spending most of its time- folded up on your back.

Weight (and to a lesser extent bulk) can make the heavier, more powerful laptops a far worse option. I always cringe when the company "standard" issues my back a heavier-than-necessary burden.

The true merit for me is performance per pound. I've found the heavier laptops, by that metric, lose ground quickly in most situations.

Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by ivthreadp110 on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:06PM (#17233828)
Upfront, I'm not a Apple person. I generally buy Business Class windows machines (after making sure I can install Linux on them). While their speakers generally arnt the best, I do enjoy the extended battery life and SSD. I mostly use them for coding laptops. I also like the "flippy" ones, but that's only because I have the tendency to carry them around by their laptop lid and this way it does not snap the neck.
Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by kwerk on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:04PM (#17234657)
Do you know how well the latest x1 yoga supports Linux? Or current “flippy” recommendation? I’m looking for something that allows me to flip the screen when I plug in external mech keyboard
Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by defoze on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:15PM (#17234444)
Just my 2c, if money isn't an issue, the latest MBP13 will be good for computing on the go. But will recommend the 256gb model since 128 is a tad too little. imo, the touchbar is just gimmicky and I have friends who don't use that at all.

MacBook is pretty but for a slight top up, you get a better processor and computing power. MBP15 might be a little too much for basic computing.

Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by praeconium on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @05:18AM (#17245554)
I have MacBook Pro and I hate it for the weight. Its older model and I switched HD, removed optical drive etc.. but its just too heavy. Forget about it. Always get lighter if You can but make sure You can upgrade RAM.
Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by justaguyhere on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @12:19PM (#17239176)
Anyone has experience with system76 serval? Weight, looks etc don't bother me as long as they function well and I can have them for at least 5 years.

Also, does adding RAM later work well?

Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by kristianp on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @01:27AM (#17235191)
What would you use on a walkabout machine exactly?
Re:Ask HN: Should I get a 2lb, 3lb or 4lb laptop? by arthev on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:46AM (#17235929)
get the 4lb laptop

grow strong