News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by tomatotomato37 on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:49AM (#17229030)
People don't buy prestige items for value, they buy them to show off the fact they can drop x amount on items with no utilitarian value
Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by josefresco on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:51AM (#17229076)
What's funny about this attitude is how little the value of your engagement ring matters once the wedding is over, and the dust settles. Maybe in certain social circles, the size/quality of an engagement ring continues to be important, but from my anecdotal experience, no one notices or cares about my wife's engagement ring, unless they are getting married soon.
Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by closeparen on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:10PM (#17229292)
The traditional purpose is to make a demonstration of your means and seriousness; that purpose is fulfilled the moment your proposal is accepted. It really only matters for a few seconds.
Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by josefresco on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:15PM (#17230490)
That's a good perspective. I'm not sure how relevant "demonstration of your means" is to modern society but "seriousness" certainly implies that it cost a significant amount. Most counter-arguments I hear object to the cost, without acknowledging that the cost is not created by the artificial scarcity of a diamonds, but rather the proposer's implied seriousness.
Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by kolpa on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:22PM (#17232613)
Sure. But I'd prefer a $10K donation to the charity of my choice, or to my student loans, or a vacation, or a car.
Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by mywittyname on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:16PM (#17229346)
Mine doesn't even wear her engagement ring anymore. Ironically, it's "too expensive" to wear day-to-day and risk losing, so it never gets worn.
Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by hospes on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:02PM (#17230350)
I recalled this joke after reading your comment, one guy working in finances asks another guy working in finances:

- How much did you pay for your tie?

- $400 in the store next door.

- They tricked you! Store across the street sells the same tie for $800.

If you are paying 10K for an engagement ring and I can buy the same exact engagement ring for 1K, it is just matter of time when your ring will loose it's "social show off value", because "everyone" will have similar rings.

I think after some time De Beers or a company similar to theirs will find for rich and/or overly emotional people something else very expensive to buy to show their "love". It is just a social signal "my ring is better than yours" => "my male ape is better than your male ape" => "I am more superior". People are social animals, social signals are very important for them, they'll always find a way to send social signals: super expensive cars, shiny things, handbags for $5K, golden iPhone for 18K, ... Look at luxury industry, it is booming.

Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by Kadin on Monday June 04, 2018 @03:19PM (#17231176)
Except that people rarely show off engagement rings once they're married.

It's not about the ring, it's about the expense. The same purpose could be served by just piling up twenty-dollar bills and setting them on fire, and the person with the biggest pile of bills to set on fire would be the highest status. There are cultures historically where stuff like that was common: generally as sacrificial offerings, but same thing really -- if you can afford to sacrifice a horse, in a culture where a horse is really valuable, it means you're really fucking serious about whatever you're doing, or so rich that you can do it casually, one of the two.

Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by kolpa on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:23PM (#17232626)
Sacrificing a horse at least served the purpose of feeding the priests.

> serious about whatever you're doing, or so rich that you can do it casually

or, the common case: bluffing and setting up for a financial and relationship disaster down the road.

Re:Ada Diamonds sells lab-grown diamonds and jewelers can't ... by eximius on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:50AM (#17229053)
Only if they're disillusioned. Many people have drunk the koolaid.