Re:Apple Passes PetroChina to Become World's Second Largest ...
by po on Friday September 24, 2010 @01:40AM
(#1722833)
I'm not sure I get what the conflict of interest is... They got a quote from an analyst who works at a fund that is heavily invested in Apple stock. They properly cite that this person has a vested interest. Why is that bad journalism?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Apple Passes PetroChina to Become World's Second Largest ...
by jfager on Friday September 24, 2010 @06:28AM
(#1723250)
The quote was completely vapid, from some random analyst with an obvious c.o.i., and totally unnecessary for the story. Why include it at all? Maybe I'm just cynical, but I read the disclosure of her position as ad copy as much as minimally responsible journalism.
Re:Apple Passes PetroChina to Become World's Second Largest ...
by po on Friday September 24, 2010 @08:18AM
(#1723405)
The whole story was pretty light reporting. You're right about that. I just didn't get why that one quote in particular struck you as being representative of bad journalism.
These stories come out all the time in the financial press: Apple hit some arbitrary milestone… lets try to get a one page story out of it. As long as they're disclosing interests, I'm ok with it.
Re:Apple Passes PetroChina to Become World's Second Largest ...
by jfager on Friday September 24, 2010 @10:25AM
(#1723716)
At the time I made the comment, the article was two paragraphs long, the first being the actual news about Apple and the second being what I quoted. It doesn't stick out from the most recent revision as much, I agree, but I still think it's a pretty bad story.
These stories come out all the time in the financial press
Which is a big reason I dislike the financial press so much. "Event + chatter from random analysts with vested interests" is a terrible template. It's lazy, boring, and uninformative, and to me counts as bad journalism even if it doesn't cross ethical lines.