News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft acquires Github by jacquesm on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:11AM (#17227888)
> So which company would you rather buy Github?

None.

It could be run as a public utility or it could be turned into something federated to absorb the bulk of the hosting costs.

Re:Microsoft acquires Github by erulabs on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:23AM (#17227991)
Only on HN / in San Francisco would the federal government (if I understand you correctly) be preferable to a technology company which has been a key player in the PC and internet marketplace for decades. I’m not trying to lionize M$, but come on - a Public Utility? As if the government doesn’t already burn enough cash....
Re:Microsoft acquires Github by jacquesm on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:24AM (#17228005)
> if I understand you correctly

You don't.

We are the public. If GitHub did an annual funding drive a-la wikipedia it would definitely keep them afloat.

A-propos, would you be OK with Microsoft buying Wikipedia?

Archive.org?

Re:Microsoft acquires Github by erulabs on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:32AM (#17228069)
Having been to the GitHub offices and having dined at their in-office restaurant, and having gotten drunk at their free bar - the answer is an asbsolute no regarding me funding then via donation. I’ll continue to fund the Linux foundation, and continue to run my own git server, and continue to enjoy the fruits of VC funding, but donations for GitHub? Insanity. I would for sure be happier if they reached profitability on their own, but that was pretty clearly not in the cards.

As for Wikipedia, I feel similarly, except Wikimedia runs a fairly tight ship, and lacking a corporate product offering (or market) means I’m much more happy to donate. They don’t run in the deep red intentionally, which is the key difference. Also, GitHub is extremely easily replaceable (and we -need- diversity in code hosting for FOSS), whereas Wikipedia is not quite so replaceable, and diversity in open encyclopedia platforms doesn’t help anyone...

Re:Microsoft acquires Github by ksk on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:27AM (#17228664)
The owners of GitHub want their money back. Just keeping it afloat doesn't achieve that.
Re:Microsoft acquires Github by scarface74 on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:49AM (#17228242)
Investors would never accept that as an exit strategy.
Re:Microsoft acquires Github by forgottenpass on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:32AM (#17228077)
That's a nice idea and all, but was there ever any path to accomplish it without asking everyone invested in GitHub to take an unforced L?

GitHub was a startup, and that comes with certain expectations and constraints on their future. But, for some crazy reason, avoiding GitHub wasn't a particularly popular position to take a week ago. People who understood the business realities of Facebook dunked on normal people for getting duped, then went around and complained that everyone should just submit to network effects and get on github.

Re:Microsoft acquires Github by chii on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:22AM (#17227990)
> run as a public utility or it could be turned into something federated

hardly worth it for the investors who want to see a 10x or even 100x ROI for their initial private funding rounds.

Public utility should be started using public funds, for the public good. Private companies can never become this.